BPSC LDC कोर्स‹› 0:00 पढ़ाई

BPSC LDC · मॉड्यूल 75 · बुनियादी स्तर · 6 min

Inference, assumption और implication

BPSC LDC इस chapter से क्या पूछता है

यह chapter सिलेबस की इन लाइनों को पढ़ाता है:

  • प्रश्नपत्र 1: सामान्य हिंदी और सामान्य अंग्रेज़ी · सामान्य अंग्रेज़ी: व्याकरण, शब्दावली, बोध और प्रयोग

इस मॉड्यूल के BPSC LDC प्रश्न अभी बैंक में जोड़े जा रहे हैं।

BPSC LDC के लिए बुनियादी स्तर तक। 25 गहरे paragraph पूरे chapter में हैं।

शून्य से शुरू: क्या कहा गया, क्या निकलता है, और क्या मान लिया गया

हर तर्क की तीन परतें होती हैं। यह छोटा कथन लीजिए:

कहा गया, निकाला गया, माना गया

The new metro line will reduce traffic on the city's main road, because many daily commuters will switch from cars to the train.

  • कहा गया: metro से traffic घटेगा; यात्री बदलकर train लेंगे।
  • निकाला गया (इससे निकलता है): main road पर कम cars की उम्मीद है।
  • माना गया (पहले से मान लिया गया): metro ऐसे रास्ते पर चलेगी जिसे यात्री सच में इस्तेमाल करते हैं, और वह इतनी सुविधाजनक होगी कि वे बदल लें।
  • संकेत (नतीजा या सुझाव): ऐसी lines बनाना भीड़ से निपटने का एक तरीक़ा है।

Inference वह है जो passage सच हो तो ज़रूर सच होगा। Assumption वह है जिसे तर्क के काम करने के लिए लेखक को मानना ही पड़ता है, भले कहा कभी न जाए। Implication वह है जो तर्क कार्रवाई या किसी जुड़ी स्थिति के लिए सुझाता है।

यह क्यों ज़रूरी है: inference, assumption और implication वाले सवाल CSAT comprehension का केंद्र हैं, और qualify और fail के बीच का फ़र्क़ ज़्यादातर इन्हीं से तय होता है।

Inference: एक छोटा, सुरक्षित क़दम

सही inference पाठ के पास रहता है। यह एक छोटा क़दम उठाता है जिसे passage मजबूर करता है, कोई लंबी छलाँग नहीं जो सिर्फ़ सच हो सकती हो।

Over the last ten years, the number of tigers in the reserve has doubled, while the area of the reserve has stayed the same.

  • ✓ The density of tigers in the reserve has increased. (यह ज़रूर निकलता है: उसी क्षेत्र में ज़्यादा बाघ।)
  • ✗ Poaching in the reserve has stopped. (हो सकता है, पर ज़रूरी नहीं; बढ़त के दूसरे कारण भी हो सकते हैं।)
  • ✗ Tiger numbers have doubled across India. (Passage से आगे जाता है, जो एक reserve की बात करता है।)
  • ✗ The reserve should now be enlarged. (यह सिफ़ारिश है, inference नहीं।)

तीन जाँचें ज़्यादातर गलत inferences हटा देती हैं।

  1. क्या पाठ इसे मजबूर करता है, या यह सिर्फ़ संभव है?
  2. क्या इसके लिए बाहरी जानकारी चाहिए? अगर हाँ, तो हटाइए।
  3. क्या इसमें चरम शब्द हैं (all, always, never, only, completely) जिनका passage समर्थन नहीं करता?

यह क्यों ज़रूरी है: ज़्यादातर गलत inference विकल्प इसलिए आकर्षक होते हैं क्योंकि वे विश्वसनीय लगते हैं, इसलिए "क्या यह सच हो सकता है?" के बजाय "क्या यह ज़रूर सच है?" पूछना ही निर्णायक आदत है।

Assumption: छिपा खंभा और negation test

Assumption तर्क के नीचे का एक छिपा खंभा है। लेखक इसे कभी नहीं कहता, लेकिन इसके बिना निष्कर्ष खड़ा नहीं रह सकता।

Negation test

The state should provide free bicycles to girls entering secondary school, because distance from school is a major reason why girls drop out.

इस तर्क के काम करने के लिए लेखक को यह मानना पड़ता है:

  • कि साइकिल सच में लड़कियों को दूरी तय करने में मदद करती है (सड़कें चलने लायक़ हैं, दूरी साइकिल से तय हो सकती है);
  • कि परिवार लड़कियों को साइकिल से स्कूल जाने देंगे।

Negation test किसी assumption की पुष्टि करता है। विकल्प को उसका उल्टा बनाइए और देखिए कि तर्क तब भी चलता है या नहीं।

  • विकल्प: Bicycles can help girls reach schools that are too far to walk to.
  • उल्टा: Bicycles cannot help girls reach distant schools.
  • अगर यह सच होता, तो तर्क गिर जाता, इसलिए विकल्प assumption है।

एक गलत विकल्प से तुलना कीजिए: Boys also drop out of school. उल्टा: Boys do not drop out. लड़कियों वाले तर्क पर कोई असर नहीं पड़ता, इसलिए यह assumption नहीं है।

यह क्यों ज़रूरी है: negation test धुँधले "क्या यह ठीक लगता है?" को एक यांत्रिक जाँच में बदल देता है, और समय के दबाव में यही चाहिए।

तेज़ दोहराव

  • Inference: passage से ज़रूर निकलता है; एक छोटा क़दम; कोई बाहरी तथ्य नहीं।
  • Assumption: अनकही मान्यता जिस पर तर्क टिका है; negation test से जाँचिए।
  • Implication: दावों का कार्रवाई या किसी जुड़ी स्थिति के लिए क्या मतलब है।
  • दोहराव assumptions नहीं हैं; बाहरी जानकारी inference नहीं है; चरम शब्द आमतौर पर हद पार करते हैं।
  • "Most logical / crucial": वह विकल्प चुनिए जिसका पूरा passage सबसे अच्छा समर्थन करे, संतुलित रूप में।
  • जोड़ने वाले शब्द (unless, only if, rather than) ख़ास ध्यान से पढ़िए।

ख़ुद को परखें

इस chapter पर exam जैसे सवाल। जवाब चुनिए, फिर उसकी व्याख्या देखिए। 22 में से 0 हल किए

  1. Passage: Many districts have opened skill-training centres for young people, but placement rates remain low. Employers say the trainees know the theory but have rarely handled real machines. A few centres have tied up with local factories so that trainees spend half their course on the shop floor. Their placement rates are nearly twice the average. Question: Which is the most logical inference?

  2. Passage: Many districts have opened skill-training centres for young people, but placement rates remain low. Employers say the trainees know the theory but have rarely handled real machines. A few centres have tied up with local factories so that trainees spend half their course on the shop floor. Their placement rates are nearly twice the average. Question: Which assumption does the argument for shop-floor training rely on?

  3. Passage: Many districts have opened skill-training centres for young people, but placement rates remain low. Employers say the trainees know the theory but have rarely handled real machines. A few centres have tied up with local factories so that trainees spend half their course on the shop floor. Their placement rates are nearly twice the average. Question: What is the most crucial message of the passage?

  4. Passage: Over the last ten years, the number of tigers in the reserve has doubled, while the area of the reserve has stayed the same. Question: Which of the following must be true?

  5. Passage: Over the last ten years, the number of tigers in the reserve has doubled, while the area of the reserve has stayed the same. Question: Why is 'Tiger numbers have doubled across India' NOT a valid inference?

  6. Passage: The state should provide free bicycles to girls entering secondary school, because distance from school is a major reason why girls drop out. Question: Which of the following is an assumption of the argument?

  7. Passage: The state should provide free bicycles to girls entering secondary school, because distance from school is a major reason why girls drop out. Question: Applying the negation test, 'Boys also drop out of school' is NOT an assumption because:

  8. Passage: The state should provide free bicycles to girls entering secondary school, because distance from school is a major reason why girls drop out. Question: Which assumption is also needed for the argument to work?

  9. Passage: Studies of flood-prone districts show that villages with intact mangroves or wetlands nearby suffer far less damage than villages where these have been cleared. Question: Which is the most logical implication?

  10. Passage: Studies of flood-prone districts show that villages with intact mangroves or wetlands nearby suffer far less damage than villages where these have been cleared. Question: Why is 'Floods are caused by clearing mangroves' not supported?

  11. Passage: A town introduced a fine for throwing garbage on the streets, and within a month the main market looked cleaner. Officials declared the fine a success and proposed it for every ward. Shopkeepers pointed out that the town had also placed new bins every fifty metres in the market during the same month. Question: The officials' conclusion assumes that:

  12. Passage: A town introduced a fine for throwing garbage on the streets, and within a month the main market looked cleaner. Officials declared the fine a success and proposed it for every ward. Shopkeepers pointed out that the town had also placed new bins every fifty metres in the market during the same month. Question: What can most reasonably be inferred from the shopkeepers' remark?

  13. Passage: A town introduced a fine for throwing garbage on the streets, and within a month the main market looked cleaner. Officials declared the fine a success and proposed it for every ward. Shopkeepers pointed out that the town had also placed new bins every fifty metres in the market during the same month. Question: Which option overreaches?

  14. Passage: When a government publishes the details of every road contract online, citizens can check whether a road was built to the promised length and quality. Such openness does not by itself prevent corruption. But it raises the chance of being caught, and officials who expect to be watched tend to behave differently. Question: Which is the most logical inference?

  15. Passage: When a government publishes the details of every road contract online, citizens can check whether a road was built to the promised length and quality. Such openness does not by itself prevent corruption. But it raises the chance of being caught, and officials who expect to be watched tend to behave differently. Question: Which assumption underlies the argument?

  16. Passage: When a government publishes the details of every road contract online, citizens can check whether a road was built to the promised length and quality. Such openness does not by itself prevent corruption. But it raises the chance of being caught, and officials who expect to be watched tend to behave differently. Question: Which option is a restatement rather than an assumption?

  17. Passage: Crop insurance in India has often failed farmers not because the idea is flawed but because claims are settled months after the loss. A farmer who must buy seed for the next season cannot wait that long. Faster settlement, using satellite data to estimate crop damage, could make insurance useful at the moment it is needed. Question: What is the most logical implication of the passage?

  18. Passage: Crop insurance in India has often failed farmers not because the idea is flawed but because claims are settled months after the loss. A farmer who must buy seed for the next season cannot wait that long. Faster settlement, using satellite data to estimate crop damage, could make insurance useful at the moment it is needed. Question: The proposal to use satellite data assumes that:

  19. Passage: Crop insurance in India has often failed farmers not because the idea is flawed but because claims are settled months after the loss. A farmer who must buy seed for the next season cannot wait that long. Faster settlement, using satellite data to estimate crop damage, could make insurance useful at the moment it is needed. Question: Which is the most rational message of the passage?

  20. Passage: Reading for pleasure in childhood is linked to better vocabulary and comprehension later in life. Yet many homes have no books other than school textbooks. Community libraries and reading corners in schools can therefore do more for learning than their modest cost suggests. Question: Which is the most logical inference?

  21. Passage: Reading for pleasure in childhood is linked to better vocabulary and comprehension later in life. Yet many homes have no books other than school textbooks. Community libraries and reading corners in schools can therefore do more for learning than their modest cost suggests. Question: Which assumption is the conclusion about libraries based on?

  22. In an inference question, an option that requires outside knowledge to accept should be:

पिछले साल के सवाल (PYQ)

UPSC CSE के पिछले साल के सवाल यहाँ तभी दिखेंगे, जब हर सवाल को official question paper से शब्दशः मिला लिया जाएगा।

अक्सर पूछे जाने वाले सवाल

ज़रूर-सही परीक्षण क्या है?

Inference तभी मान्य है जब गद्यांश सही रहते वह ग़लत न हो सके।

'सही हो सकता है' वाले विकल्प ग़लत क्यों हैं?

क्योंकि उन्हें अतिरिक्त जानकारी चाहिए जो गद्यांश नहीं देता।

Implication, inference से कैसे अलग है?

Implication वह व्यावहारिक नतीजा है जिसकी ओर गद्यांश इशारा करता है; inference कोई भी ज़रूर निकलने वाला निष्कर्ष है।

क्या inference गद्यांश को दोहरा सकता है?

दोहराव सही होता है पर आमतौर पर inference सवाल वह नहीं माँगता।