HPSC HCS · मॉड्यूल 72 · मेन्स स्तर · 16 min
Inference, assumption और implication
HPSC HCS इस chapter से क्या पूछता है
यह chapter सिलेबस की इन लाइनों को पढ़ाता है:
- प्रारंभिक प्रश्नपत्र II: CSAT · बोधगम्यता
- मुख्य परीक्षा · अंग्रेज़ी: सार-लेखन, गद्यांश, निबंध, प्रयोग, व्याकरण
HPSC HCS ने इस chapter से 10 प्रश्न पूछे हैं (2021); पूरे मॉड्यूल से 15।
पूरे स्तर पर: बुनियाद, स्टैंडर्ड हिस्सा और मेन्स विश्लेषण।
शून्य से शुरू: क्या कहा गया, क्या निकलता है, और क्या मान लिया गया
हर तर्क की तीन परतें होती हैं। यह छोटा कथन लीजिए:
The new metro line will reduce traffic on the city's main road, because many daily commuters will switch from cars to the train.
- कहा गया: metro से traffic घटेगा; यात्री बदलकर train लेंगे।
- निकाला गया (इससे निकलता है): main road पर कम cars की उम्मीद है।
- माना गया (पहले से मान लिया गया): metro ऐसे रास्ते पर चलेगी जिसे यात्री सच में इस्तेमाल करते हैं, और वह इतनी सुविधाजनक होगी कि वे बदल लें।
- संकेत (नतीजा या सुझाव): ऐसी lines बनाना भीड़ से निपटने का एक तरीक़ा है।
Inference वह है जो passage सच हो तो ज़रूर सच होगा। Assumption वह है जिसे तर्क के काम करने के लिए लेखक को मानना ही पड़ता है, भले कहा कभी न जाए। Implication वह है जो तर्क कार्रवाई या किसी जुड़ी स्थिति के लिए सुझाता है।
यह क्यों ज़रूरी है: inference, assumption और implication वाले सवाल CSAT comprehension का केंद्र हैं, और qualify और fail के बीच का फ़र्क़ ज़्यादातर इन्हीं से तय होता है।
Inference: एक छोटा, सुरक्षित क़दम
सही inference पाठ के पास रहता है। यह एक छोटा क़दम उठाता है जिसे passage मजबूर करता है, कोई लंबी छलाँग नहीं जो सिर्फ़ सच हो सकती हो।
Over the last ten years, the number of tigers in the reserve has doubled, while the area of the reserve has stayed the same.
- ✓ The density of tigers in the reserve has increased. (यह ज़रूर निकलता है: उसी क्षेत्र में ज़्यादा बाघ।)
- ✗ Poaching in the reserve has stopped. (हो सकता है, पर ज़रूरी नहीं; बढ़त के दूसरे कारण भी हो सकते हैं।)
- ✗ Tiger numbers have doubled across India. (Passage से आगे जाता है, जो एक reserve की बात करता है।)
- ✗ The reserve should now be enlarged. (यह सिफ़ारिश है, inference नहीं।)
तीन जाँचें ज़्यादातर गलत inferences हटा देती हैं।
- क्या पाठ इसे मजबूर करता है, या यह सिर्फ़ संभव है?
- क्या इसके लिए बाहरी जानकारी चाहिए? अगर हाँ, तो हटाइए।
- क्या इसमें चरम शब्द हैं (all, always, never, only, completely) जिनका passage समर्थन नहीं करता?
यह क्यों ज़रूरी है: ज़्यादातर गलत inference विकल्प इसलिए आकर्षक होते हैं क्योंकि वे विश्वसनीय लगते हैं, इसलिए "क्या यह सच हो सकता है?" के बजाय "क्या यह ज़रूर सच है?" पूछना ही निर्णायक आदत है।
Assumption: छिपा खंभा और negation test
Assumption तर्क के नीचे का एक छिपा खंभा है। लेखक इसे कभी नहीं कहता, लेकिन इसके बिना निष्कर्ष खड़ा नहीं रह सकता।
The state should provide free bicycles to girls entering secondary school, because distance from school is a major reason why girls drop out.
इस तर्क के काम करने के लिए लेखक को यह मानना पड़ता है:
- कि साइकिल सच में लड़कियों को दूरी तय करने में मदद करती है (सड़कें चलने लायक़ हैं, दूरी साइकिल से तय हो सकती है);
- कि परिवार लड़कियों को साइकिल से स्कूल जाने देंगे।
Negation test किसी assumption की पुष्टि करता है। विकल्प को उसका उल्टा बनाइए और देखिए कि तर्क तब भी चलता है या नहीं।
- विकल्प: Bicycles can help girls reach schools that are too far to walk to.
- उल्टा: Bicycles cannot help girls reach distant schools.
- अगर यह सच होता, तो तर्क गिर जाता, इसलिए विकल्प assumption है।
एक गलत विकल्प से तुलना कीजिए: Boys also drop out of school. उल्टा: Boys do not drop out. लड़कियों वाले तर्क पर कोई असर नहीं पड़ता, इसलिए यह assumption नहीं है।
यह क्यों ज़रूरी है: negation test धुँधले "क्या यह ठीक लगता है?" को एक यांत्रिक जाँच में बदल देता है, और समय के दबाव में यही चाहिए।
Implication और "the most logical message"
Implication, inference से एक क़दम आगे जाता है: यह पूछता है कि passage के दावों का कार्रवाई के लिए या किसी जुड़ी स्थिति के लिए क्या मतलब है।
Studies of flood-prone districts show that villages with intact mangroves or wetlands nearby suffer far less damage than villages where these have been cleared.
- Implication: Protecting mangroves and wetlands can be part of flood management.
- Implication नहीं: Floods are caused by clearing mangroves. (Passage नुक़सान की बात करता है, कारण की नहीं।)
CSAT सवाल अक्सर most logical, most rational या most crucial inference या message पूछते हैं। इन शब्दों का मतलब है कि आपको वह विकल्प चुनना है जिसका पूरा passage सबसे अच्छा समर्थन करता है, भले दो विकल्प संभव लगें।
- जो विकल्प passage के मुख्य ज़ोर को दिखाए, उसे किसी किनारे की टिप्पणी वाले विकल्प पर तरजीह दीजिए।
- चरम दावे के बजाय संतुलित दावे को चुनिए।
- जिस विकल्प से लेखक सहमत होगा, उसे उस पर तरजीह दीजिए जिसका लेखक सिर्फ़ ज़िक्र करता है।
यह क्यों ज़रूरी है: "most logical" वाले सवाल विवेक को अंक देते हैं, और ऊपर की तीन तरजीहें दो विकल्पों के बीच के कठिन चुनाव को तर्क से भरा चुनाव बना देती हैं।
ये सवाल कठिन क्यों हैं, और examiners इन्हें कैसे बनाते हैं
ये सवाल इसलिए कठिन हैं क्योंकि गलत विकल्प झूठे नहीं, बल्कि असमर्थित होते हैं। विषय के बारे में बहुत जानने वाला उम्मीदवार ख़ास तौर पर जोखिम में रहता है, क्योंकि बाहरी जानकारी से कई विकल्प सच लगने लगते हैं।
Examiners आमतौर पर चार विकल्प ऐसे बनाते हैं:
- एक सही विकल्प, जो passage से कसकर जुड़ा हो।
- एक दोहराव, जो सच है पर सवाल जो पूछता है वह नहीं है (assumption वाले सवाल में यह कहा गया है, माना नहीं गया)।
- एक हद पार करने वाला, जिसमें चरम शब्द या बड़ा दायरा हो।
- एक बाहरी जानकारी वाला विकल्प, जो दुनिया में सच है पर पाठ में नहीं है।
Hindi-माध्यम के पाठक कभी-कभी इसलिए अंक खो देते हैं क्योंकि वे हर पंक्ति का ध्यान से अनुवाद करते हैं, पर तर्क जोड़ने वाले शब्द (unless, only if, rather than) चूक जाते हैं। यही शब्द तय करते हैं कि क्या निकलता है और क्या माना गया है, इसलिए इन्हें ख़ास ध्यान से पढ़िए।
Exam इसे कैसे परखता है: CSAT पूछता है "Which of the following is the most logical inference / assumption / crucial message?" और "With reference to the passage, the following assumptions have been made ... Which is/are valid?" Mains English आपसे अपने शब्दों में समझाने को कहता है कि किसी sentence का क्या संकेत है।
यह क्यों ज़रूरी है: जब दिख जाता है कि हर गलत विकल्प चार में से किसी एक प्रकार का है, तो आप अंदाज़ा लगाने के बजाय भरोसे से विकल्प हटा पाते हैं।
दूसरा passage: inference और negation test, विकल्प-दर-विकल्प
Negation test बताना आसान है और दबाव में लगाना कठिन। यह हिस्सा उसे धीरे-धीरे, हर विकल्प पर, लगाता है ताकि आदत बन जाए। Passage हमारा अपना है और aptitude paper के आम पाठ के पैटर्न पर चलता है: सिफ़ारिश के साथ एक छोटा तर्क।
Comprehension में assumption वाले सवाल सबसे कठिन क्यों होते हैं? क्योंकि उत्तर, परिभाषा से ही, passage में लिखा नहीं होता। आपको देखना होता है कि लेखक ने क्या मान लिया। Negation test उस अदृश्य कदम को एक यांत्रिक जाँच बना देता है: विकल्प को नकारिए, और देखिए कि तर्क गिरता है या नहीं।
Many state governments now give bicycles to girls who enter secondary school. Where the scheme has run for several years, the number of girls continuing to Class 10 has risen noticeably, especially in villages far from a high school. Distance, it seems, was keeping girls at home more than lack of interest. If the aim is to keep girls in school, governments should consider safe and affordable transport as important as classrooms and teachers.
Q1. Which of the following can be validly inferred from the passage?
- (a) Girls in villages near a high school did not benefit from the scheme at all. ज़्यादा खींचा गया: passage कहता है कि दूर वाले गाँवों में बढ़त ज़्यादा थी, यह नहीं कि पास वालों में बिल्कुल नहीं थी।
- (b) For some girls, distance to school was a barrier to continuing their education. मान्य: passage आँकड़ों से ठीक यही निष्कर्ष निकालता है।
- (c) Boys do not face any difficulty in reaching school. Passage से बाहर: लड़कों की बात नहीं है।
- (d) Cycles are the cheapest form of transport. बाहरी ज्ञान।
- उत्तर: (b)।
Q2. The author's argument assumes that
- (a) the rise in girls continuing to Class 10 was caused mainly by the bicycles and not by some other change during the same years.
- नकारिए: बढ़त मुख्य रूप से किसी और वजह से हुई, जैसे नए स्कूल या छात्रवृत्ति। तब परिवहन वाला तर्क गिर जाता है। मान्य assumption।
- (b) bicycle schemes are run by state governments.
- यह कहा गया है, माना नहीं गया। दोहराव कभी उत्तर नहीं होता।
- (c) girls are more intelligent than boys.
- नकारिए: लड़कियाँ ज़्यादा बुद्धिमान नहीं। तर्क पर कोई असर नहीं। Assumption नहीं।
- (d) every girl in India owns a bicycle.
- नकारिए: हर लड़की के पास साइकिल नहीं। तर्क पर असर नहीं; वह योजना के प्रभाव के बारे में है। Assumption नहीं।
- उत्तर: (a)।
Q3. Which of the following, if true, would most weaken the argument?
- (a) The same years saw new high schools opened in many of the villages studied. कमज़ोर करता है: कोई दूसरा कारण बढ़त समझा सकता है।
- (b) Girls who received cycles reported enjoying the ride. असंबद्ध।
- (c) The scheme was popular with parents. कारण वाले दावे से असंबद्ध।
- (d) Some girls shared their cycles with siblings. दावे पर असर नहीं।
- उत्तर: (a)। ध्यान दीजिए कि कमज़ोर करने वाला विकल्प ठीक उसी assumption पर चोट करता है जो Q2 में मिला।
Q4. The most logical implication for policy is that
- (a) all schools should be closed and replaced with bicycles. बेतुका चरम।
- (b) plans to raise girls' schooling should account for the practical difficulty of reaching school. आख़िरी वाक्य से सीधे निकलता है।
- (c) teachers are no longer needed. विरोध करता है as important as classrooms and teachers का।
- (d) only girls should receive any government support. ज़्यादा खींचा गया।
- उत्तर: (b)।
याद रखने वाला पैटर्न: मान्य inference संयत वाला था; assumption छिपी कारण-कड़ी थी; और सबसे अच्छा कमज़ोर करने वाला विकल्प उसी कड़ी पर चोट करता था। कई passages में ये तीनों सवाल तर्क के एक कमज़ोर जोड़ के इर्द-गिर्द बनते हैं।
एक मौलिक passage पर हल किए गए सवाल
यह passage पढ़िए, जो अभ्यास के लिए लिखा गया है।
Many districts have opened skill-training centres for young people, but placement rates remain low. Employers say the trainees know the theory but have rarely handled real machines. A few centres have tied up with local factories so that trainees spend half their course on the shop floor. Their placement rates are nearly twice the average.
सवाल 1. Which is the most logical inference?
- (a) All training centres should be closed. (b) Practical experience during training appears to improve job placement. (c) Factories prefer to hire graduates. (d) Theory is useless in technical work.
- (b) तुलना से निकलता है; (a) और (d) चरम हैं, और (c) कहा ही नहीं गया।
- उत्तर: (b)।
सवाल 2. Which assumption does the author's argument rely on?
- (a) The higher placement rate of tied-up centres is due mainly to shop-floor training, not to other differences between centres. (b) Placement rates remain low. (c) Every district has a factory. (d) Employers dislike theory.
- (b) कहा गया है, माना नहीं गया। (a) को उल्टा कीजिए: अगर ऊँची दर किसी और वजह से होती, तो shop-floor training वाला तर्क गिर जाता।
- उत्तर: (a)।
सवाल 3. What is the most crucial message?
- (a) Skill training should include substantial hands-on work with employers. (b) Young people do not want jobs. (c) Theory classes should be longer. (d) Factories should run all schools.
- (a) passage के ज़ोर को संतुलित रूप में पकड़ता है।
- उत्तर: (a)।
Mains lens: अपनी लिखाई में तर्कों की जाँच
जो औज़ार CSAT के सवाल हल करते हैं, वही Mains उत्तरों को मज़बूत बनाते हैं। कोई सिफ़ारिश लिखने से पहले पूछिए कि आप क्या मान रहे हैं।
- जब आपका मुख्य assumption साफ़ न हो, तो उसे कहिए: Provided that roads are usable, free bicycles can reduce dropouts.
- छिपी छलाँगों से बचिए: बिना सबूत के a scheme was launched से the problem is solved पर मत कूदिए।
- Implications साफ़ निकालिए: If learning lags behind enrolment, the focus of funding should shift from buildings to teaching.
- चरम दावों को सीमित कीजिए: often, in many districts, appears to से दावे बचाव-योग्य बनते हैं।
हमारे बनाए अभ्यास सवाल (पिछले सालों के प्रश्नपत्र नहीं): इन्हें English में ही हल कीजिए।
- Identify two assumptions in: Banning plastic bags will clean our rivers.
- Write one valid inference and one invalid inference from the tiger-reserve sentence in this chapter, and explain why the second is invalid.
- In two sentences, state the implication of the skill-training passage for district administrators.
तेज़ दोहराव
- Inference: passage से ज़रूर निकलता है; एक छोटा क़दम; कोई बाहरी तथ्य नहीं।
- Assumption: अनकही मान्यता जिस पर तर्क टिका है; negation test से जाँचिए।
- Implication: दावों का कार्रवाई या किसी जुड़ी स्थिति के लिए क्या मतलब है।
- दोहराव assumptions नहीं हैं; बाहरी जानकारी inference नहीं है; चरम शब्द आमतौर पर हद पार करते हैं।
- "Most logical / crucial": वह विकल्प चुनिए जिसका पूरा passage सबसे अच्छा समर्थन करे, संतुलित रूप में।
- जोड़ने वाले शब्द (unless, only if, rather than) ख़ास ध्यान से पढ़िए।
इस chapter से HPSC HCS के प्रश्न
Passage (Q85-88, English only): Scientific studies remind us of our kinship with animals, but philosophy is needed to understand its meaning. Midgley argued that the philosopher's job is twofold: to examine how dichotomies such as man and beast work on our imaginations, and to bring forth new images that free us from them. Humans have exceptional capacities; language transforms natural activities and gives us power to alter our environment far beyond other animals. Anscombe noted that language lets us get people to promise or sign contracts. Technology, industry, culture and art depend on such cooperation; money and trade reshape desires, property rights reshape territorial instincts, and 'we farm at an industrial scale and eat other animals not just because we are hungry, but because to do so culturally signifies wealth or status.' Midgley held that our environmental salvation lies in language, through metaphor and metre. (Full passage on booklet page 28.) Which of the following options best describes the given statement? We farm at an industrial scale and eat other animals not just because we are hungry, but because to do so culturally signifies wealth or status.
प्रश्न मूल अंग्रेज़ी में; हिंदी अनुवाद जल्द।
- (a) Human beings consume meat in a large scale
- (b) Abundance and prestige drive human beings to act independent of their needs
- (c) It is a common practice to eat animals whether one is hungry or not
- (d) Most of the farming is done only for commercial purpose
उत्तर देखें
(b) Abundance and prestige drive human beings to act independent of their needs · हमारा उत्तर; आधिकारिक कुंजी की प्रतीक्षा
Passage (Q89-92, English only): Hazlitt writes that Macbeth is built on a stronger principle of contrast than any other Shakespeare play: 'The action is desperate, and the reaction is dreadful', with sudden transitions from triumph to despair. Macbeth completes the tragic quartet with Hamlet, Othello and King Lear. Like Hamlet it treats the consequences of regicide, but from the usurpers' side; like Othello it centres on husband and wife; like Lear it explores female villainy in Lady Macbeth. Unlike Hamlet and Othello, whose tragic action comes at the climax, Macbeth, like Lear, puts the tipping point at the outset. Shakespeare's shortest tragedy, it cuts subplots to focus on the crime's impact. 'What is singular about Macbeth, compared to the other three great Shakespearean tragedies, is its villain-hero.' Hamlet mainly executes rather than murders, Othello is 'more sinned against than sinning', Lear is 'a very foolish fond old man', while Macbeth knowingly chooses evil and treats coldblooded, premeditated murder from the killer's view. (Full passage on booklet page 29.) Match the characters in column 1 with their description in column 2. Column 1: (a) Hamlet (b) Othello (c) Macbeth (d) King Lear Column 2: (i) Sinner (ii) Coldblooded (iii) Foolish (iv) Executioner
प्रश्न मूल अंग्रेज़ी में; हिंदी अनुवाद जल्द।
- (a) (a)-(iv), (b)-(iii), (c)-(ii), (d)-(i)
- (b) (a)-(ii), (b)-(iii), (c)-(i), (d)-(iv)
- (c) (a)-(iii), (b)-(ii), (c)-(i), (d)-(iv)
- (d) (a)-(iv), (b)-(i), (c)-(ii), (d)-(iii)
उत्तर देखें
(d) (a)-(iv), (b)-(i), (c)-(ii), (d)-(iii) · हमारा उत्तर; आधिकारिक कुंजी की प्रतीक्षा
Passage (Q89-92, English only): Hazlitt writes that Macbeth is built on a stronger principle of contrast than any other Shakespeare play: 'The action is desperate, and the reaction is dreadful', with sudden transitions from triumph to despair. Macbeth completes the tragic quartet with Hamlet, Othello and King Lear. Like Hamlet it treats the consequences of regicide, but from the usurpers' side; like Othello it centres on husband and wife; like Lear it explores female villainy in Lady Macbeth. Unlike Hamlet and Othello, whose tragic action comes at the climax, Macbeth, like Lear, puts the tipping point at the outset. Shakespeare's shortest tragedy, it cuts subplots to focus on the crime's impact. 'What is singular about Macbeth, compared to the other three great Shakespearean tragedies, is its villain-hero.' Hamlet mainly executes rather than murders, Othello is 'more sinned against than sinning', Lear is 'a very foolish fond old man', while Macbeth knowingly chooses evil and treats coldblooded, premeditated murder from the killer's view. (Full passage on booklet page 29.) Which of the following inferences can be made from the lines "What is singular about Macbeth, compared to the other three great Shakespearean tragedies, is its villain-hero."
प्रश्न मूल अंग्रेज़ी में; हिंदी अनुवाद जल्द।
- (a) No kind of comparison is drawn between the four tragedies written by Shakespeare.
- (b) Among the four tragedies written by Shakespeare, Macbeth is less of a tragedy.
- (c) The protagonists from other tragedies are less coldblooded than Macbeth is
- (d) Unlike the villains from other tragedies, Macbeth is vengeful and ambitious in his plans.
उत्तर देखें
(c) The protagonists from other tragedies are less coldblooded than Macbeth is · हमारा उत्तर; आधिकारिक कुंजी की प्रतीक्षा
Passage (Q89-92, English only): Hazlitt writes that Macbeth is built on a stronger principle of contrast than any other Shakespeare play: 'The action is desperate, and the reaction is dreadful', with sudden transitions from triumph to despair. Macbeth completes the tragic quartet with Hamlet, Othello and King Lear. Like Hamlet it treats the consequences of regicide, but from the usurpers' side; like Othello it centres on husband and wife; like Lear it explores female villainy in Lady Macbeth. Unlike Hamlet and Othello, whose tragic action comes at the climax, Macbeth, like Lear, puts the tipping point at the outset. Shakespeare's shortest tragedy, it cuts subplots to focus on the crime's impact. 'What is singular about Macbeth, compared to the other three great Shakespearean tragedies, is its villain-hero.' Hamlet mainly executes rather than murders, Othello is 'more sinned against than sinning', Lear is 'a very foolish fond old man', while Macbeth knowingly chooses evil and treats coldblooded, premeditated murder from the killer's view. (Full passage on booklet page 29.) Which of the following statements do NOT find a support in the given passage?
प्रश्न मूल अंग्रेज़ी में; हिंदी अनुवाद जल्द।
- (a) King Lear and Hamlet are longer when compared to the tragedy Macbeth
- (b) The climax of the plays Othello and Hamlet showcases the element of tragedy
- (c) The contrast element is less in the other tragedies than that is seen in Macbeth
- (d) In Macbeth, the reactions are terrible, and most actions depict a despair
Passage (Q93-96, English only): India is the second largest fish producer, employing over 14 million people. Overfishing, pollution and destructive practices threaten the ecosystem; nearly 70% of by-catch (unwanted juvenile fish) is discarded, though the seas' ability to replenish depends on these juveniles. Diamond-shaped nets close up in water, but square mesh nets keep their shape and let juvenile fish escape. The square mesh net was introduced in Sindhudurg through a Government of Maharashtra-UNDP partnership supported by the GEF, with technical help from the Central Institute of Fisheries Technology. 'Met with initial scepticism in this important fish landing centre, the initiative has gone a long way.' 'Since 2015, every trawler in the district now uses square mesh nets.' Income rose by ₹10,000 a month as diesel use fell, and on an average 18 kg catch over 3 kg of juveniles escape. Maharashtra has proposed making square mesh mandatory for all 17,000 trawlers, and fishermen along the western coast are adopting it, earning more and paving the way for policy change. (Full passage on booklet page 30.) From the passage identify the TRUE and FALSE statements. (a) Using square nets by fishermen can curtail overfishing. (b) The practice of adopting square nets is financially sustainable. (c) Fishermen were always enthusiastic about using square nets. (d) Young fish cannot survive when farmers use square nets extensively. (e) In the near future, many states are likely to insist that fishermen use square nets.
प्रश्न मूल अंग्रेज़ी में; हिंदी अनुवाद जल्द।
- (a) (a)-T, (b)-T, (c)-T, (d)-F, (e)-T
- (b) (a)-T, (b)-T, (c)-F, (d)-F, (e)-F
- (c) (a)-F, (b)-T, (c)-F, (d)-T, (e)-T
- (d) (a)-T, (b)-T, (c)-F, (d)-F, (e)-T
उत्तर देखें
(d) (a)-T, (b)-T, (c)-F, (d)-F, (e)-T · हमारा उत्तर; आधिकारिक कुंजी की प्रतीक्षा
Passage (Q93-96, English only): India is the second largest fish producer, employing over 14 million people. Overfishing, pollution and destructive practices threaten the ecosystem; nearly 70% of by-catch (unwanted juvenile fish) is discarded, though the seas' ability to replenish depends on these juveniles. Diamond-shaped nets close up in water, but square mesh nets keep their shape and let juvenile fish escape. The square mesh net was introduced in Sindhudurg through a Government of Maharashtra-UNDP partnership supported by the GEF, with technical help from the Central Institute of Fisheries Technology. 'Met with initial scepticism in this important fish landing centre, the initiative has gone a long way.' 'Since 2015, every trawler in the district now uses square mesh nets.' Income rose by ₹10,000 a month as diesel use fell, and on an average 18 kg catch over 3 kg of juveniles escape. Maharashtra has proposed making square mesh mandatory for all 17,000 trawlers, and fishermen along the western coast are adopting it, earning more and paving the way for policy change. (Full passage on booklet page 30.) Which of the following can be inferred from the statement "Since 2015, every trawler in the district now uses square mesh nets"?
प्रश्न मूल अंग्रेज़ी में; हिंदी अनुवाद जल्द।
- (a) Fishing has become sustainable in Sindhudurg since 2015.
- (b) After 2015 in Sindhudurg farmers were allowed to sell only big fish.
- (c) Before 2015 sale of only juvenile fish dominated the Sindhudurg fish market.
- (d) There was a very strong movement by farmers against square mesh nets in 2015.
उत्तर देखें
(a) Fishing has become sustainable in Sindhudurg since 2015. · हमारा उत्तर; आधिकारिक कुंजी की प्रतीक्षा
Passage (Q93-96, English only): India is the second largest fish producer, employing over 14 million people. Overfishing, pollution and destructive practices threaten the ecosystem; nearly 70% of by-catch (unwanted juvenile fish) is discarded, though the seas' ability to replenish depends on these juveniles. Diamond-shaped nets close up in water, but square mesh nets keep their shape and let juvenile fish escape. The square mesh net was introduced in Sindhudurg through a Government of Maharashtra-UNDP partnership supported by the GEF, with technical help from the Central Institute of Fisheries Technology. 'Met with initial scepticism in this important fish landing centre, the initiative has gone a long way.' 'Since 2015, every trawler in the district now uses square mesh nets.' Income rose by ₹10,000 a month as diesel use fell, and on an average 18 kg catch over 3 kg of juveniles escape. Maharashtra has proposed making square mesh mandatory for all 17,000 trawlers, and fishermen along the western coast are adopting it, earning more and paving the way for policy change. (Full passage on booklet page 30.) Which of the following inferences can be drawn from the lines about income rising by INR 10,000 a month as diesel consumption fell, and over 3 kg of juvenile fish escaping from an average 18 kg catch?
प्रश्न मूल अंग्रेज़ी में; हिंदी अनुवाद जल्द।
- (a) The new technology adopted is leading to the escape of 3 kgs of juvenile fish.
- (b) Square mesh nets are profitable for the farmer and his savings will also increase.
- (c) When diesel consumption and juvenile fish capture increase, it is unsafe for marine biodiversity.
- (d) By adopting square mesh nets all farmers will capture at least 21 kgs of fish.
उत्तर देखें
(b) Square mesh nets are profitable for the farmer and his savings will also increase. · हमारा उत्तर; आधिकारिक कुंजी की प्रतीक्षा
Passage (Q97-100, English only): 'The rich have many assets; the poor have only one - their labour. Because good jobs are slow to come to the poor, the poor must move to find productive employment.' Migration is the most effective way to reduce poverty. Migrants' incomes rise three to six times when they move to richer countries, but 'these gains remain largely notional because most people cannot move'; only about 3% of people live outside their birth country, and national borders are the main barrier. 'The gains for immigrants do not come at the expense of host countries' because hosts benefit from complementary skills and the products and services immigrants provide. Yet there is stark political opposition to immigration, and economists attribute it to cultural and social factors, including xenophobia. (Full passage on booklet page 31.) From the lines "These gains remain largely notional because most people cannot move" it can be inferred that
प्रश्न मूल अंग्रेज़ी में; हिंदी अनुवाद जल्द।
- (a) People are made to move to other countries against their wishes.
- (b) Theoretically migration is likely to look like a boon to many.
- (c) People migrate to another country only with the intention of gains.
- (d) Any form of gains for the migrants is only temporary and permanent.
उत्तर देखें
(b) Theoretically migration is likely to look like a boon to many. · हमारा उत्तर; आधिकारिक कुंजी की प्रतीक्षा
Passage (Q97-100, English only): 'The rich have many assets; the poor have only one - their labour. Because good jobs are slow to come to the poor, the poor must move to find productive employment.' Migration is the most effective way to reduce poverty. Migrants' incomes rise three to six times when they move to richer countries, but 'these gains remain largely notional because most people cannot move'; only about 3% of people live outside their birth country, and national borders are the main barrier. 'The gains for immigrants do not come at the expense of host countries' because hosts benefit from complementary skills and the products and services immigrants provide. Yet there is stark political opposition to immigration, and economists attribute it to cultural and social factors, including xenophobia. (Full passage on booklet page 31.) The statement from the passage "The gains for immigrants do not come at the expense of host countries" means
प्रश्न मूल अंग्रेज़ी में; हिंदी अनुवाद जल्द।
- (a) The immigrants can make a comfortable living only if the host countries agree.
- (b) The immigrants are contributing to the host countries and not the other way.
- (c) The host countries do not have to make any sacrifices to accommodate immigrants.
- (d) The host countries will have to spend a lot of their resources to maintain immigrants.
उत्तर देखें
(c) The host countries do not have to make any sacrifices to accommodate immigrants. · हमारा उत्तर; आधिकारिक कुंजी की प्रतीक्षा
Passage (Q97-100, English only): 'The rich have many assets; the poor have only one - their labour. Because good jobs are slow to come to the poor, the poor must move to find productive employment.' Migration is the most effective way to reduce poverty. Migrants' incomes rise three to six times when they move to richer countries, but 'these gains remain largely notional because most people cannot move'; only about 3% of people live outside their birth country, and national borders are the main barrier. 'The gains for immigrants do not come at the expense of host countries' because hosts benefit from complementary skills and the products and services immigrants provide. Yet there is stark political opposition to immigration, and economists attribute it to cultural and social factors, including xenophobia. (Full passage on booklet page 31.) Which of the following can be inferred from the statement "Because good jobs are slow to come to the poor, the poor must move to find productive employment"?
प्रश्न मूल अंग्रेज़ी में; हिंदी अनुवाद जल्द।
- (a) Productive employment is not in the reach of the locals from host countries
- (b) Economically sound people have greater chances of finding lucrative jobs
- (c) To find profitable employment one should not be an immigrant in a host country.
- (d) Poor people have no chance of getting a lucrative job in their own country.