KPSC KAS course‹› 0:00 studied

KPSC KAS · Module 26 · Mains depth · 19 min

ಮೂಲಭೂತ ಹಕ್ಕುಗಳು: ಸಮಾನತೆ (ವಿಧಿ 12 ರಿಂದ 18)

What KPSC KAS asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Paper I: General Studies · ಭಾರತದ ರಾಜನೀತಿ ಮತ್ತು ಆರ್ಥಿಕತೆ.
  • GS 2 · ಭಾರತೀಯ ಸಂವಿಧಾನ ಮತ್ತು ರಾಜನೀತಿ.

KPSC KAS has asked 2 questions from this chapter (2020); 4 from its whole module.

Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.

Start from zero: why do we need rights against the State?

Picture a village cricket ground. Most players are boys of ten or twelve. One player is a giant: the tallest, strongest, and he also owns the bat, the ball and the ground. If there were no rules, he could bat all day, change the score when he liked and send anyone home.

So the boys write a few rules on a board, and they agree that a respected teacher will settle any fight:

  • "Everyone follows the same rules, even the giant."
  • "No one is sent home without a fair reason."
  • "Everyone may speak, but no one may abuse others."
  • "If the giant breaks a rule, go to the teacher, and the teacher's word is final."

In a country, the giant is the State: the government, Parliament, the police, the municipality. It has the most power: it makes laws, collects taxes and can arrest people. Fundamental Rights are the rules on the board that even the State must follow, and the teacher is the court, which can strike down anything that breaks them.

That is the whole idea of this chapter: power is necessary, but it must have limits, and those limits must be enforceable.

Where the rights live, and who gets them

The Fundamental Rights sit in Part III of the Constitution, Articles 12 to 35. Part III itself puts them under six headings:

The six groups of Fundamental Rights in Part III
  1. Right to Equality (Articles 14 to 18)
  2. Right to Freedom (Articles 19 to 22)
  3. Right against Exploitation (Articles 23 and 24)
  4. Right to Freedom of Religion (Articles 25 to 28)
  5. Cultural and Educational Rights (Articles 29 and 30)
  6. Right to Constitutional Remedies (Article 32)

This chapter covers Articles 12 and 13 and the Right to Equality. The Right to Freedom is explained in Fundamental Rights: freedom, life and liberty (Articles 19 to 22), and the other four groups are in Fundamental Rights: exploitation, religion, culture and remedies (Articles 23 to 35).

Every person or citizens only?

Person or citizen? Read each Article carefully, because the word used matters:

  • Some rights are for every person, including foreigners in India: for example Articles 14, 20 and 21. A tourist arrested in Patna still has the right to life and personal liberty.
  • Others are only for citizens: for example Articles 15, 16 and 19. A foreign national cannot claim equal opportunity in government jobs or the freedom to settle anywhere in India.

Two Articles that make the rest work

Article 12: who is "the State"? Rights protect you against the State, so we must know who the State is. Article 12 says "the State" includes:

Who counts as 'the State'?
  • the Government and Parliament of India;
  • the Government and the Legislature of each State;
  • all local or other authorities within India or under the control of the Government of India.

So your municipality, panchayat and many public bodies are also "the State". A rude private shopkeeper is not, but a government office is.

Who are the "other authorities"? In Ramana Dayaram Shetty v International Airport Authority (1979), the Supreme Court held that rights can be enforced against any body that is an agency or instrumentality of the State. To decide, the court asks who set the body up, who controls it and its policies, and who takes its profits. So a statutory corporation like LIC, a government company like SAIL and a nationalised bank like SBI all count as "the State".

Article 13: the "void" button. This is what gives the rights teeth.

  • Article 13(1): laws that existed before 1950 are void to the extent they clash with Part III.
  • Article 13(2): the State shall not make any law that takes away or abridges these rights; any such law is void to that extent.
  • Article 13(3)(a): "law" is read widely. It includes any Ordinance, order, bye-law, rule, regulation, notification, custom or usage that has the force of law. So the State cannot escape by calling something a "rule" instead of a "law".

Constitutional amendments are treated differently. Article 13(4) says Article 13 does not apply to a constitutional amendment made under Article 368.

Article 14: the same rules for everyone

Article 14 says: the State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India.

Equal treatment of equals

Two phrases, two ideas:

  • Equality before the law: no one is above the law. A minister and a rickshaw puller face the same law and the same courts.
  • Equal protection of the laws: people in similar situations must be treated alike. This does not mean everyone gets identical treatment.

Does equality mean "same for all"? Think of a sports day. Children under 14 and adults do not run in the same race; that is not unfair, because the groups are genuinely different and the purpose (a fair race) justifies the split. The State can likewise group people (by age, income, profession) for a law, as long as the grouping is reasonable and linked to the law's purpose. What it cannot do is pick on people arbitrarily.

Example: an income-tax law with higher rates for higher incomes is fine. A law that taxes only people named "Sharma" is not.

Article 15: no discrimination by birth or belief

Article 15(1): the State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth or any of them.

Places no one can be kept out of

Notice the word "only". The State may treat people differently for other genuine reasons, but never just because of these five things.

Article 15(2) goes further and reaches into everyday public life. No citizen can be barred, on these grounds, from:

  • shops, public restaurants, hotels and places of public entertainment; or
  • wells, tanks, bathing ghats, roads and places of public resort maintained wholly or partly by State funds or dedicated to public use.

This clause was written for a society where people were once kept away from wells and roads because of caste. It applies even to private shops and hotels.

Article 15(3): nothing stops the State from making special provisions for women and children. So reserved seats for women in buses, or special schemes for girls' education, do not violate Article 15.

Article 16: an equal chance at government jobs

Article 16(1): there shall be equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters of employment or appointment to any office under the State.

Article 16: grounds that cannot block a government job

Article 16(2) lists the grounds that can never make a citizen ineligible for a government job: religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth, residence. Compare this with Article 15: Article 16 adds two more grounds, descent (family line) and residence.

Article 16(3): the one exception on residence. Only Parliament can make a law requiring residence within a State or Union territory for certain jobs there. A State Legislature cannot do this on its own. This keeps the job market of the whole country open to every citizen.

Example: an advertisement for a government teacher's post that says "only men may apply" breaks Article 16; so does one that says "only sons of existing employees".

Equality that allows special help

Treating everyone the same is not always fair. If one runner starts 50 metres behind, "equal rules" keep him behind. So Articles 15 and 16 carry clauses that let the State help those who start behind:

Same race, different starting lines
  • Article 15(4) (added by the 1st Amendment, 1951): special provisions for socially and educationally backward classes, SCs and STs.
  • Article 15(5) (added by the 93rd Amendment, 2005): such provisions can cover admission to educational institutions, including private ones (aided or unaided), but not minority institutions.
  • Article 16(4): reservation of posts for any backward class that, in the State's opinion, is not adequately represented in government jobs.
  • Article 16(4A): reservation in promotion, with consequential seniority, for SCs and STs not adequately represented.
  • Article 16(4B): reserved vacancies left unfilled in a year can be carried forward, and they are not counted towards the 50 per cent ceiling of the year in which they are filled.
  • Articles 15(6) and 16(6) (added by the 103rd Amendment, 2019): up to 10 per cent for economically weaker sections (EWS) who are not already covered by the other reservations.

So the Constitution sees two kinds of equality: equal rules (Article 14) and equal chances (special help for those held back).

How the courts have read equality

The text of Articles 14 to 16 is short, so the courts have had to work out how far equality goes. Two ideas from their rulings shape most exam questions.

How the courts have read equality

Equality also means no arbitrariness. The Supreme Court has held that Article 14 embodies the principle of non-arbitrariness. So a law or an order that is plainly unreasonable can break equality, even if it uses the same words for everyone. This test of manifest arbitrariness was applied to test a law in Shayara Bano v. Union of India.

A ceiling on reservation. In 1992, the Supreme Court held that the total number of reservations could not exceed 50 per cent. In 2019, the 103rd Amendment brought economically weaker sections into the scope of reservation, so the ceiling and its basis are still debated.

Reservation in private education. In cases such as T.M.A. Pai Foundation, the Supreme Court held that the State could not make reservations in privately run institutes. Parliament answered with the 93rd Amendment (2005), which added Article 15(5). In Ashoka Kumar Thakur v Union of India (2008), the Court upheld the 27 per cent OBC quota in IITs, IIMs and other Central educational institutions, but excluded the creamy layer from it.

Articles 17 and 18: ending old hierarchies

Article 17: untouchability. "Untouchability" is abolished, and its practice in any form is forbidden. Enforcing any disability arising out of untouchability is an offence punishable in accordance with law. This is one of the few Fundamental Rights that is directly aimed at private individuals as well as the State: a person who stops someone from using a village well because of caste commits an offence.

Untouchability is forbidden in any form
Untouchability is forbidden in any formPhoto: Unknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Article 18: titles. A society of equals should not have lords and nobles.

Article 18: no titles
  • 18(1): the State shall not confer any title, except military or academic distinctions. So a gallantry award or a doctorate is allowed, but not "Raja" or "Sir".
  • 18(2): no citizen of India shall accept any title from a foreign State.
  • 18(3) and 18(4): a person holding an office of profit or trust under the State needs the President's consent to accept a foreign title, or any present, emolument or office from a foreign State.

Why it matters: British India had given titles to loyal subjects. Article 18 says that in a republic, honour comes from service, not from rank.

Why each right was written in, and what it changed

Every right in Articles 12 to 18 answers a wrong that people had lived through, such as unequal treatment under colonial rule or exclusion by caste. Read the table as "problem, then answer".

Right Why it was needed What it changed
Art 13: laws against rights are void A list of rights means little if an ordinary law can override it Courts can strike down laws, old and new, that clash with Part III
Art 14: equality before law Under colonial rule, rules were often applied unequally Every person, citizen or not, gets the same law and equal protection
Art 15 and 16: no discrimination; equal chance in jobs Caste, religion and sex decided who entered a well, a temple or an office Public places and government jobs are open to all citizens
Art 15(4), 16(4): special help Same rules for very unequal people can keep the gap alive Reservation and special provisions became part of equality, not an exception to it
Art 17: untouchability abolished A whole section of society was treated as "untouchable" Practising it in any form became an offence

The big picture. These Articles turn promises into limits on the State. The State can still act, but it has to follow the rules the Constitution sets, and a court can check it.

Why it matters today. Debates on reservation and on caste discrimination all begin here. A strong answer names the wrong each right was meant to fix, and then asks whether the limit on that right is still fair.

Mains lens: equal rules or equal chances?

A second common question: "Reservation is an exception to equality." Do you agree?

Formal equality vs real equality

Two ideas of equality:

  • Formal equality: the same rule for everyone (Article 14's "equality before the law"). On this view, any special treatment looks like an exception.
  • Substantive equality: real equality of outcome and opportunity, which may need special help for those held back by history. On this view, Articles 15(4), 15(5), 16(4) and 16(4A) are not exceptions but ways of achieving equality.

How the text supports substantive equality:

  • Article 15(3) and 15(4) begin "Nothing in this article shall prevent the State...": the Constitution itself says special provisions are compatible with equality.
  • Article 16(4) ties reservation to being "not adequately represented": the aim is fair representation, not favour.
  • Article 16(4B) mentions a 50 per cent ceiling, which shows a limit: special help cannot swallow the general rule.

Concerns to mention: benefits may go mostly to the better-off within a group; there is a need for good data on representation; and EWS reservation (15(6), 16(6)) adds an economic test alongside the social one, which raises the question of what "backwardness" should mean.

Conclusion: reservation is best seen as equality's instrument, within limits. The challenge is to keep it targeted, time-bound in spirit, and backed by better schools and jobs for all.

Mains practice: more questions, different angles

Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton; add facts from this chapter.

1. Scope: "Some Fundamental Rights belong to every person, others only to citizens." Explain with reasons.

  • Name the rights for every person: Articles 14, 20 and 21.
  • Name the rights for citizens only: Articles 15, 16 and 19.
  • Give the reason: political and job rights are tied to membership of the nation, while life and a fair trial belong to every human being.
  • Conclude that the line shows what India treats as universal.

2. Social justice: How does the EWS quota (103rd Amendment) change the idea of backwardness in Articles 15 and 16?

  • Explain the earlier basis: reservation was tied to social and educational backwardness, and to SCs and STs.
  • Then explain the 2019 change: up to 10% reservation for economically weaker sections.
  • Present the debate between income and caste as the basis for special help.
  • Conclude that equality of opportunity now has more than one meaning.

Quick revision

One-page summary
  • Fundamental Rights are in Part III, Articles 12 to 35, in six groups, and this chapter covers the Right to Equality (Articles 14 to 18) along with Articles 12 and 13.
  • Under Art 12, "the State" includes the Union and State governments and legislatures, and local or other authorities. Art 13 makes clashing laws void, and "law" includes an ordinance, rule or custom; 13(4) keeps constitutional amendments out of it.
  • Art 14 gives every person equality before law and equal protection of the laws. Art 15 bars discrimination on religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth; 15(2) covers shops, hotels, wells, ghats and roads, and 15(3) allows special provisions for women and children.
  • Art 16 gives equal opportunity in public jobs; 16(2) adds descent and residence as barred grounds, and under 16(3) only Parliament can set a residence rule.
  • Special help is allowed by 15(4) (1st Amendment, 1951), 15(5) (93rd, 2005) and 16(4). 16(4A) allows reservation in promotion, 16(4B) allows carry-forward of vacancies with a 50% ceiling, and 15(6)/16(6) allow 10% EWS reservation (103rd, 2019).
  • Art 17 abolishes untouchability and makes its practice an offence. Art 18 allows no titles except military or academic ones, and citizens cannot accept foreign titles.

KPSC KAS questions from this chapter

  1. 2020 · KPSC KAS Prelims · Paper I, General Studies (subject code 388), 100 questions, 200 marks · 2 marks

    The 124th Constitution Amendment Bill, 2019 pertains to ____________ .

    1. (a) Merging of nationalized banks
    2. (b) Scrapping the special status of Jammu and Kashmir
    3. (c) Same-sex marriage
    4. (d) Reservation for economically weaker sections in Government jobs and education
    Show answer

    (d) Reservation for economically weaker sections in Government jobs and education

  2. 2020 · KPSC KAS Prelims · Paper II, General Studies with Karnataka and aptitude (subject code 389), 100 questions, 200 marks · 2 marks

    The Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order (Second Amendment) Bill, 2019 has been passed to include three Scheduled Tribes of Karnataka. They are _________ .

    1. (a) Parivara, Talwara and Siddi
    2. (b) Dond, Shikari and Misbi
    3. (c) Naga, Gondawa and Sapru
    4. (d) Chapri, Tribupa and Budhi
    Show answer

    (a) Parivara, Talwara and Siddi

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 15 answered

  1. Untouchability is abolished by:

  2. Which of these Fundamental Rights is available only to citizens?

  3. Consider the following statements: 1. Article 15(4) was added by the First Amendment. 2. Article 15(5) allows special provisions for admission in private educational institutions, including minority institutions. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  4. Reservation for economically weaker sections (EWS) was enabled by which amendment?

  5. Under Article 12, 'the State' does NOT expressly include:

  6. Consider the following statements about Article 13: 1. Under Article 13, 'law' includes a custom or usage having the force of law. 2. Laws made before 26 January 1950 cannot be declared void under Article 13. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  7. Article 15(2) bars denial of access, on grounds such as caste or religion, to all of these EXCEPT:

  8. Which clause allows the State to make special provisions for women and children?

  9. Consider the following statements about equality in public employment: 1. Article 16(2) bars discrimination in public employment on grounds of descent and residence. 2. A State Legislature can prescribe a residence requirement for jobs under that State. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  10. Article 16(4B) allows unfilled reserved vacancies of a year to be:

  11. A citizen holding an office of profit under the State wants to accept a present from a foreign State. Under Article 18 this needs the consent of:

  12. The general ceiling of 50 per cent on total reservations comes from:

  13. The principle of non-arbitrariness has been read into which Article?

  14. The 'agency or instrumentality of the State' test under Article 12 was laid down in:

  15. Ashoka Kumar Thakur v Union of India (2008) upheld:

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

What does Article 14 guarantee?

Equality before the law and equal protection of the laws to every person in India. Courts also read a rule against arbitrariness into it.

Which Fundamental Rights are available only to citizens?

Articles 15, 16 and 19, among others, are only for citizens. Rights such as Articles 14, 20 and 21 are for every person, including foreigners.

Who counts as 'the State' under Article 12?

The Government and Parliament of India, the government and legislature of each State, and all local or other authorities in India or under the control of the Government of India.

Does Article 18 ban all titles?

It abolishes titles conferred by the State, but military and academic distinctions are allowed.