BPSC AE course‹› 0:00 studied

BPSC AE · Module 23 · standard depth · 16 min

Compressibility and consolidation: how much and how fast clay settles

What BPSC AE asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Paper 5: Civil Engineering I · Soil mechanics: nature, formation and properties of soils, consolidation and compaction, shear strength
  • Paper 5: Civil Engineering I · Foundation engineering: slopes, soil stresses, bearing capacity, earth pressure, retaining walls, piles, rafts, wells, machine foundations, expansive soils

BPSC AE questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for BPSC AE. 3 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: why some buildings keep sinking

Press a wet sponge with your hand. Water runs out at once, and the sponge gets thinner. Now imagine a sponge with pores so tiny that water takes months to escape. You press it today, and it keeps getting thinner for years.

Saturated clay is that slow sponge. Its grains and water cannot be squeezed into a smaller volume, so the soil can shrink only when water leaves the pores. Because clay pores are extremely fine, the water escapes very slowly, and the settlement goes on long after the building is finished.

The slow squeezing out of water from a saturated soil under a steady load is called consolidation. Sand also gives up water when loaded, but its large pores let water out almost at once, so a sand settles mainly while it is being loaded.

An engineer needs two answers for any structure on clay: how much will it settle, and how fast. This chapter gives both, starting from the idea of effective stress.

Why it matters. Many cracks in buildings on soft clay come from consolidation, especially when one part settles more than another. Embankments for highways and railways over soft ground need settlement estimates before the road is paved, or the surface will sink and crack.

How load moves from water to grains

A simple model shows what happens inside clay. Think of a closed cylinder full of water, with a spring inside and a piston on top. The piston has a tiny hole, like a valve. The spring stands for the soil skeleton, and the water stands for the pore water.

When a load is placed on the piston, water cannot escape at first, and water hardly compresses. So at the first instant the water carries the whole load, and the pore pressure rises by exactly the applied stress. This extra pressure is called the excess pore pressure. The spring carries nothing yet, so the effective stress has not changed.

Slowly, water leaks through the hole. As it leaves, the piston moves down, the spring compresses and starts taking load. The excess pore pressure falls, and the effective stress rises by the same amount. At the end, all the excess pore pressure has gone, and the spring carries the whole load.

In real clay, the hole is the network of fine pores, and the rate of leakage depends on the permeability k and on how far the water must travel to reach a free-draining layer. Terzaghi turned this picture into an equation. He assumed that the load stays constant, that water flows and soil strains only vertically, and that k and the compressibility stay constant during the process.

Why it matters. This model explains why a clay foundation is weakest just after loading. The load has arrived, but the effective stress, and with it the strength, has not yet increased. That is why fast filling of an embankment on soft clay can cause it to fail.

Three parts of settlement

The total settlement of a structure on clay has three parts, which happen at different times:

  • Immediate (elastic) settlement happens as the load is applied. The soil changes shape at constant volume, compressing vertically and bulging sideways, with no water leaving.
  • Primary consolidation happens as the excess pore pressure dissipates and water leaves the pores. In clays it is usually the largest part, and it can take months to many years.
  • Secondary compression continues after the excess pore pressure has gone. The grains slowly rearrange under the constant effective stress, much like creep.

For most inorganic clays, primary consolidation is the main part, and it can be estimated reasonably well. Secondary compression becomes important in highly organic soils and peat, where it can be large.

Under a wide load, such as a large raft or a long embankment, the soil far from the edges compresses vertically without spreading sideways. Such one-dimensional compression is what the laboratory consolidation test reproduces, and it is the basis of the methods in this chapter.

Why it matters. Mixing up the three parts leads to wrong decisions. A road engineer who sees settlement still continuing after the pore pressure has dissipated is watching secondary compression, which drains or preloading cannot remove completely.

Compressibility and the e versus log σ′ curve

In the consolidation (oedometer) test, a disc of undisturbed clay sits in a rigid ring between porous stones, so it can drain at the top and bottom but cannot spread sideways. Loads are added in steps, and for each one the compression is read with time until it stops. The final void ratio for each load gives a curve of void ratio e against effective stress σ′.

On an ordinary scale, the curve flattens as the stress rises, because the soil gets denser and stiffer. Its slope is the coefficient of compressibility, av = −Δe/Δσ′. Dividing by (1 + e0) gives the coefficient of volume compressibility, mv = av/(1 + e0), which is the compression per unit thickness for a unit increase in stress.

Plotted against log σ′, the curve for a clay loaded beyond anything it has felt before becomes a straight line, called the virgin compression line. Its slope is the compression index, Cc = −Δe/Δ(log₁₀ σ′). A widely used rough estimate for normally consolidated clays is Cc ≈ 0.009(wL − 10), with the liquid limit wL in percent.

If the sample is unloaded and reloaded, it swells only a little and then recompresses along a much flatter line, of slope Cs. When the stress passes the old maximum, the curve rejoins the virgin line. That old maximum is the preconsolidation stress, σ′pc. Casagrande's construction finds it from the point of sharpest curvature: draw a tangent and a horizontal line there, bisect the angle between them, and extend the straight virgin line back to meet the bisector.

The ratio of σ′pc to the present effective stress is the over-consolidation ratio, OCR = σ′pc/σ′.

  • If OCR = 1, the clay is normally consolidated (NC): it has never carried more than it carries now.
  • If OCR > 1, it is over-consolidated (OC): it once carried more, perhaps under soil since eroded away, from a past change in the groundwater level, or from repeated drying.

An OC clay settles much less under a new load, because it first moves along the flat recompression line.

Why it matters. Finding σ′pc is often the most valuable result of the whole site investigation. A crust of dried, over-consolidated clay on top of a soft deposit can carry a light building safely, while the same load on the soft NC clay below would settle many times more.

How much will it settle?

The soil grains do not change volume, so a clay layer of thickness H shortens in the same proportion as its total volume. If the void ratio falls by Δe from an initial e0, the settlement is:

S = H Δe/(1 + e0).

Using the coefficient of volume compressibility, this becomes S = mv Δσ′ H. This form is handy for a small range of stress, where mv is roughly constant.

For a normally consolidated clay, Δe can be taken from the virgin line, which gives:

S = [Cc H/(1 + e0)] log₁₀[(σ′0 + Δσ′)/σ′0].

Here σ′0 is the present effective stress at the middle of the layer, and Δσ′ is the increase caused by the new load at the same depth. A thick layer is divided into thinner sub-layers, and their settlements are added.

A worked example. A normally consolidated clay layer is 4 m thick, with e0 = 1.0 and Cc = 0.3. At its middle, σ′0 = 80 kPa, and a new building adds Δσ′ = 40 kPa there. Then S = (0.3 × 4/2.0) × log₁₀(120/80) = 0.6 × 0.176 = 0.106 m, or about 106 mm.

If the same clay were over-consolidated with σ′pc above 120 kPa, the change would follow the flatter recompression line, and the settlement would be only a fraction of this.

Why it matters. A settlement of 100 mm may be acceptable for a raft that settles evenly, but the same amount under one column and not the next can crack frames and walls. The settlement estimate decides whether a simple footing will do or a raft or piles are needed.

How fast will it settle?

Terzaghi's theory combines Darcy's law with the volume change of the soil. The rate of consolidation is controlled by one soil constant, the coefficient of consolidation:

cv = k/(mv γw).

A clay consolidates faster if it is more permeable (larger k) or less compressible (smaller mv), because less water has to pass, or it passes more easily.

Time enters through a dimensionless time factor, Tv = cv t/d². Here d is the drainage path, the longest distance a water particle must travel to reach a free-draining layer.

  • With double drainage, such as clay between two sand layers, water leaves from both faces, so d = H/2.
  • With single drainage, such as clay resting on rock, water leaves from one face only, so d = H.

The average degree of consolidation U, the fraction of final settlement reached, depends only on Tv. Two useful results are:

  • For U up to 60%, Tv = (π/4)U². For example, for U = 50%, Tv = 0.785 × 0.25 ≈ 0.197.
  • For U = 90%, Tv = 0.848.

In the laboratory, cv is found from the compression-time readings for each load, by the square-root-of-time method, which gives t90, or the logarithm-of-time method, which gives t50.

A worked example. A clay layer 4 m thick lies between two sand layers, and cv = 2 m² per year. With double drainage, d = 2 m, so the time for 90% consolidation is t90 = 0.848 × 2²/2 ≈ 1.7 years. If the bottom were rock instead, d = 4 m and t90 = 0.848 × 16/2 ≈ 6.8 years, four times longer.

Why it matters. Because time grows with d², the most powerful way to speed up consolidation is to shorten the drainage path. This is exactly what vertical drains do.

Putting it to work: preloading and drains

Engineers rarely just wait for consolidation. They use the theory to make most of the settlement happen before the structure is finished.

Preloading means placing a temporary load, often an extra height of embankment called a surcharge, on the soft clay before construction. The clay consolidates under it, and when the surcharge is removed, the clay is over-consolidated with respect to the final load. Later settlement is then small.

Vertical drains are columns of sand or prefabricated plastic strips installed at close spacing through the clay. They give water a short horizontal path to a drain instead of a long vertical path to the top or bottom. Since time depends on the square of the drainage path, cutting it from several metres to about a metre can bring years of waiting down to months.

Staged construction is the third tool. Because a soft clay is weakest just after loading, a high embankment is raised in stages. Each stage waits until enough pore pressure has dissipated and the clay has gained strength before the next lift is placed. Piezometers in the ground show when it is safe to continue.

Why it matters. Highways, railway lines and ports on soft coastal or riverine clay are built this way. A JE or AE supervising such work reads settlement plates and piezometers, and must know what the readings mean before allowing paving or the next lift.

Quick revision

  • Consolidation is the slow escape of water from saturated soil under a steady load, and it matters most in clays.
  • At the instant of loading, the excess pore pressure equals the applied stress; as it dissipates, effective stress rises and the clay settles.
  • Total settlement = immediate + primary consolidation + secondary compression.
  • av = −Δe/Δσ′, mv = av/(1 + e0), and Cc is the slope of e against log σ′.
  • OCR = σ′pc/σ′; NC clay has OCR = 1, and OC clay settles much less.
  • S = H Δe/(1 + e0) = mv Δσ′ H, and for NC clay S = [Cc H/(1 + e0)] log₁₀[(σ′0 + Δσ′)/σ′0].
  • cv = k/(mv γw) and Tv = cv t/d², with d = H/2 for double drainage and d = H for single drainage.
  • Tv = (π/4)U² up to 60%, T50 ≈ 0.197 and T90 = 0.848.
  • Time is proportional to d², which is why vertical drains speed up consolidation so much.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 12 answered

  1. Consolidation of a saturated clay under a steady load is mainly due to:

  2. Immediately after a load Δσ is applied to a saturated clay, the excess pore water pressure is:

  3. Settlement that continues after the excess pore pressure has fully dissipated is called:

  4. A clay whose present effective stress is less than its preconsolidation stress is:

  5. Casagrande's construction on the e-log σ′ curve is used to find:

  6. The coefficient of volume compressibility mv is related to av by:

  7. An NC clay layer 4 m thick has e0 = 1.0 and Cc = 0.3; at mid-depth σ′0 = 80 kPa and Δσ′ = 40 kPa. The consolidation settlement is about:

  8. The coefficient of consolidation is given by:

  9. A clay layer under double drainage takes 2 years for 90% consolidation. If it were drained on one face only, the time would be:

  10. A 4 m clay layer between sand layers has cv = 2 m²/year. The time for 90% consolidation (T90 = 0.848) is about:

  11. For an average degree of consolidation of 40%, the time factor is about:

  12. In the consolidation test, the square-root-of-time fitting method gives:

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between NC and OC clay?

NC clay has never carried more effective stress than it does now (OCR = 1). OC clay once carried more (OCR > 1) and settles much less.

What is the drainage path in consolidation?

It is the longest distance water travels to a draining layer: half the thickness for double drainage and the full thickness for single drainage.

What is the time factor for 90% consolidation?

T90 is 0.848. For degrees up to 60%, Tv = (π/4)U², which gives T50 of about 0.197.

How do vertical drains speed up consolidation?

They shorten the drainage path, and since time grows with its square, settlement that would take years can finish in months.