BPSC AE course‹› 0:00 studied

BPSC AE · Module 23 · standard depth · 22 min

Index properties and soil classification: grain size, Atterberg limits and the IS system

What BPSC AE asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Paper 5: Civil Engineering I · Soil mechanics: nature, formation and properties of soils, consolidation and compaction, shear strength
  • Paper 5: Civil Engineering I · Foundation engineering: slopes, soil stresses, bearing capacity, earth pressure, retaining walls, piles, rafts, wells, machine foundations, expansive soils

BPSC AE questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for BPSC AE. 3 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: sugar, flour and dough

Think of three things in a kitchen. Sugar is made of separate grains that pour freely, and when you wet it, it does not become sticky. Dry flour is so fine that it rises as dust, and wet flour becomes dough that you can roll and shape.

Soils behave in the same three ways. Gravel and sand act like sugar, silt acts like dry flour, and clay acts like dough. Two questions decide which family a soil belongs to: how big are the grains, and how does the soil behave with water?

The numbers that answer these questions are called index properties. They are cheap and quick to measure, and they do not give strength or settlement directly. What they give is an "index", a first reliable guess of how the soil will behave, so the engineer knows which detailed tests to order.

This chapter covers grain size and grading, the minerals that make clays special, the Atterberg limits, and finally the Indian Standard system that gives every soil a two-letter name such as SW or CI.

Why it matters. A soil report on a highway or a building begins with these names. Two engineers in different states who read "CH" understand at once that the soil is a highly plastic clay, which can swell, shrink and settle a lot. A common language saves time and prevents dangerous misunderstandings.

Grain size: from boulders to clay

Soil grains range from boulders bigger than 300 mm to clay particles smaller than 0.002 mm, a difference of more than a hundred thousand times. The Indian Standard divides this range into named sizes:

Name Size range
Boulder Larger than 300 mm
Cobble 80 to 300 mm
Gravel (G) 4.75 to 80 mm: coarse 20 to 80, fine 4.75 to 20
Sand (S) 0.075 to 4.75 mm: coarse 2 to 4.75, medium 0.425 to 2, fine 0.075 to 0.425
Silt (M) 0.002 to 0.075 mm
Clay (C) Smaller than 0.002 mm

The most important dividing line is 0.075 mm (75 microns). Particles coarser than this are separated by sieves, while finer particles are too small to sieve. The soil is first washed on the 75 micron sieve to remove the fines, and the coarse part is then dried and shaken through a stack of sieves, from 4.75 mm down to 75 microns, for about ten minutes.

For the fines, we use sedimentation. The soil is mixed with water and a deflocculating agent, so the particles do not stick together, and then allowed to settle. Large particles fall faster than small ones, so a hydrometer reading taken at a known depth and time tells how much soil is still in suspension. From that, the size of the particles that have already settled can be calculated.

The results are plotted as a grading curve: percentage finer on the vertical axis and grain size on a logarithmic horizontal axis. A log scale is used because the sizes span so many orders of magnitude.

Why it matters. The share of fines decides whether water can drain out of a soil quickly. Sands and gravels drain freely and are used for filters and drainage layers. Soils with many fines hold water, so a road base made from them turns weak in the rains.

Reading the grading curve: Cu and Cc

From the grading curve we read three sizes. D10 is the size than which 10% of the soil is finer, and D30 and D60 are defined the same way. D10 is called the effective size, because the finest tenth of the grains largely controls how fast water flows through a sand.

Two coefficients describe the shape of the curve:

  • The coefficient of uniformity is Cu = D60 / D10. It tells how wide the range of sizes is.
  • The coefficient of curvature is Cc = D30² / (D60 × D10). It tells whether the middle sizes are present in the right amounts.

A single-sized soil has Cu = Cc = 1. A well-graded soil has all sizes, so small grains fill the gaps between big ones and the soil packs densely. As a general guide, Cc between 1 and 3 shows good grading, while Cu below 3 shows a uniform soil. The Indian Standard sets the well-graded limits as Cu greater than 4 for gravel and Cu greater than 6 for sand, with Cc between 1 and 3 in both cases.

A poorly graded soil fails these limits. It may be uniform, with nearly one size, or gap graded, with some middle sizes missing, which shows as a flat step in the curve.

A quick example. A sand has D10 = 0.12 mm, D30 = 0.35 mm and D60 = 0.80 mm. Then Cu = 0.80/0.12 = 6.7 and Cc = 0.35²/(0.80 × 0.12) = 0.1225/0.096 = 1.28. Since Cu is above 6 and Cc lies between 1 and 3, the sand is well graded, and if it has very few fines its symbol is SW.

Why it matters. Well-graded material compacts to a high density with less effort, which is why it is chosen for road sub-base and railway blanket layers. Uniform sand is easy to drain but hard to compact and quick to erode, so it needs a filter or a confining layer.

Why clays are different: minerals and adsorbed water

Sand and silt grains are small pieces of the parent rock, mostly quartz, and they behave like tiny stones. Clay is different because chemical weathering has turned the rock into new clay minerals. These minerals are built from very thin sheets of silica and of aluminium or magnesium hydroxide stacked on each other.

Because they are sheets, clay particles are flaky. Some are only one-hundredth as thick as they are long, so a gram of clay has a huge surface area. These surfaces carry a negative electric charge, which attracts positive ions and a layer of water molecules. This tightly held adsorbed water is what makes clay sticky and mouldable, which we call plasticity.

Three clay minerals matter most:

  • Kaolinite has two-layer units held together by strong hydrogen bonds. Water cannot enter between the units, so kaolinite is stable, and it is the most common mineral in residual clays.
  • Montmorillonite has three-layer units held by weak van der Waals forces. Water enters easily between the units, so the mineral swells a great deal when wet and shrinks when dry.
  • Illite also has three-layer units, but potassium ions bind them firmly. It is stable and does not swell much.

Soils rich in montmorillonite are called expansive soils. The black soils of central and western India are the best-known example in our country. In the rains they swell and lift light structures, and in summer they shrink and crack, so walls, floors and canal linings on them crack again and again.

Why it matters. The BPSC AE syllabus names "stabilisation of expansive soils" directly, because so much public infrastructure sits on such ground. Knowing the mineral explains the remedies: replace the soil, keep its moisture constant, mix in lime, or carry the load deeper with under-reamed piles.

Atterberg limits: the four states of a fine soil

Take a lump of dry clay and keep adding water. At first it is hard and brittle like a brick, which is the solid state. With more water it becomes crumbly (semi-solid), then it can be rolled and moulded without cracking (plastic), and finally it flows like a thick paste (liquid).

The water contents at which the soil passes from one state to the next are the consistency limits, also called Atterberg limits:

  • The shrinkage limit wS is the water content below which drying no longer reduces the volume of the soil.
  • The plastic limit wP is the water content at which a soil thread just begins to crumble when rolled to 3 mm diameter.
  • The liquid limit wL is the water content at which the soil passes from plastic to liquid.

The plasticity index IP = wL − wP is the range of water content over which the soil stays plastic. Sands have no plasticity, so their IP is zero, while highly plastic clays can have IP above 40%.

In the standard liquid-limit test, soil passing the 425 micron sieve is mixed into a paste, placed in the brass cup of the Casagrande device and cut with a grooving tool. The cup is dropped by turning the handle at two revolutions per second, and the number of blows needed to close the groove over 13 mm is counted. Readings are taken at several water contents between 10 and 40 blows, and the water content at 25 blows is the liquid limit.

Two more indices compare the soil's natural water content w with its limits:

  • The liquidity index is LI = (w − wP)/IP. A value above 1 means the soil is in a liquid state, values between 0 and 0.25 mean it is stiff, and a value below 0 means it is semi-solid.
  • The consistency index is IC = (wL − w)/IP, which equals 1 − LI. A high IC means a firm soil.

Clays can also be compared by their activity, which is IP divided by the percentage of clay-size particles. Activity below 0.75 is called inactive, 0.75 to 1.25 normal, and above 1.25 active, and active clays usually contain montmorillonite.

Why it matters. A clay whose natural water content is close to its liquid limit (LI near 1) is very soft and will settle a lot under a new embankment. A high activity warns of swelling, and both readings come from a cheap test done in an afternoon.

The Indian Standard classification system

Grain size and plasticity together give every soil a name in the Indian Standard system. The name uses one or two letters. The first letter is the main soil type: G for gravel, S for sand, M for silt, C for clay, O for organic soil and Pt for peat. The second letter gives a property: W for well graded, P for poorly graded, M or C for silty or clayey fines, and L, I or H for low, intermediate or high plasticity.

Step 1: coarse or fine? If more than 50% of the soil by weight is coarser than 0.075 mm, it is coarse-grained. If more than 50% is finer, it is fine-grained.

Step 2 for coarse soils. If more than half of the coarse fraction is larger than 4.75 mm, the soil is a gravel (G), and otherwise it is a sand (S). Then the fines decide the second letter:

  • With less than 5% fines, the grading decides: GW or GP, SW or SP.
  • With more than 12% fines, the plasticity of the fines decides: GM or GC, SM or SC.
  • With 5% to 12% fines, the soil gets a dual symbol such as SW-SM or GP-GC.

Step 2 for fine soils. Fine soils are named from the plasticity chart, which plots IP against wL. The sloping A-line has the equation IP = 0.73(wL − 20). Soils plotting above it are clays (C), and soils below it are silts (M) or organic soils (O). Two vertical lines at wL = 35% and 50% set the plasticity: L below 35%, I from 35% to 50%, and H above 50%.

This gives nine fine-soil groups: ML, MI, MH, CL, CI, CH, OL, OI and OH. Highly organic, fibrous soils are simply called peat (Pt). The international Unified system is similar, but it has only two plasticity bands (L and H) split at wL = 50%, so the "intermediate" I group is special to the Indian Standard.

Why it matters. Each group symbol carries a ready set of expected behaviour. A GW is an excellent foundation and road material, an SP drains well but needs confinement, and a CH or MH swells, settles and loses strength when wet. Specifications for embankments and subgrades are written in these symbols, so the AE must be fluent in them.

Worked examples in classification

Example 1: a fine-grained soil. A soil has 85% passing the 75 micron sieve, a liquid limit of 48% and a plastic limit of 26%. Its clay-size content is 55% and its natural water content is 39%. Classify it and comment on its state.

  1. Since 85% passes 75 microns, the soil is fine-grained.
  2. The plasticity index is IP = 48 − 26 = 22%.
  3. On the A-line at wL = 48%, IP = 0.73 × (48 − 20) = 20.4%. The soil's IP of 22% is above this, so it is a clay.
  4. Because wL lies between 35% and 50%, the plasticity is intermediate, and the soil is CI.
  5. The liquidity index is LI = (39 − 26)/22 = 0.59, which places the clay in the soft range.
  6. The activity is 22/55 = 0.40, which is below 0.75, so the clay is inactive and unlikely to swell much.

Example 2: a coarse-grained soil. A soil has 3% passing 75 microns and 92% passing 4.75 mm, with D10 = 0.12 mm, D30 = 0.35 mm and D60 = 0.80 mm.

  1. Only 3% is fine, so the soil is coarse-grained.
  2. Only 8% of the soil is retained on 4.75 mm, which is far less than half of the coarse part (97%), so the soil is a sand.
  3. The fines are below 5%, so the grading decides the second letter.
  4. Cu = 6.7 is above 6 and Cc = 1.28 lies between 1 and 3, so the soil is SW, a well-graded sand.

Why it matters. These two examples are exactly what a JE writes in a soil report and what an objective paper asks in one line. Working them step by step also shows why one number alone, such as liquid limit, never classifies a soil on its own.

Field identification and railway soil classes

On site there is often no laboratory at hand, yet the engineer must still describe the soil in a trial pit. A handful of soil rubbed between the fingers already tells a lot. Sand grains can be seen with the naked eye and feel gritty, while silt feels smooth, becomes dusty when dry and brushes off the hands easily.

Clay is sticky when wet and hard when dry, and it has to be scraped or washed off the hands. A moist clay can also be rolled into a long thin thread and squeezed into a ribbon, which a silt cannot do. These quick checks help decide where to take samples and which tests to order.

Some departments use their own classes for special works. Indian Railways, for example, groups soils for the formation of new lines by the share of fines finer than 75 microns. Soil quality class SQ1 has more than 50% fines, SQ2 has 12% to 50%, and SQ3 has less than 12%. The blanket layer just below the ballast must be a well-graded granular material, with Cu above 7 and Cc between 1 and 3.

Try it yourself. The guided soil gradation lab on ujjwalinfra takes you through a sieve analysis from weighing to the grading curve. It then works out Cu and Cc and gives the railway soil quality class with a full data sheet and report.

Why it matters. Field description is the first line of defence against a bad foundation. A JE who notices sticky, shiny clay in a trial pit for a culvert can raise the alarm before concrete is poured. On railway and highway projects, the class of the soil decides how thick the blanket or sub-base must be, which directly changes the cost of the work.

Quick revision

  • The key size limits are 4.75 mm between gravel and sand, 0.075 mm between sand and silt, and 0.002 mm between silt and clay.
  • Coarse fractions are sized by sieving, and the fraction below 75 microns by hydrometer sedimentation.
  • Cu = D60/D10 and Cc = D30²/(D60 × D10), and well-graded soils need Cu above 4 (gravel) or 6 (sand) with Cc from 1 to 3.
  • Kaolinite is stable, illite is fairly stable, and montmorillonite swells and shrinks strongly.
  • The order of the Atterberg limits is wS < wP < wL, and IP = wL − wP.
  • The liquid limit is the water content at 25 blows, and the plastic limit is where a 3 mm thread crumbles.
  • LI = (w − wP)/IP and IC = (wL − w)/IP, and the two always add up to 1.
  • Activity is IP divided by the percentage of clay, and active clays have values above 1.25.
  • A soil is coarse-grained when more than 50% is coarser than 75 microns, and fine-grained otherwise.
  • The A-line is IP = 0.73(wL − 20), clays plot above it, and L, I and H split at wL of 35% and 50%.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 11 answered

  1. As per the Indian Standard, the boundary between sand and silt is at:

  2. The particle size distribution of the fraction finer than 75 microns is found by:

  3. A soil has D10 = 0.1 mm, D30 = 0.3 mm and D60 = 0.9 mm. Its Cu and Cc are:

  4. For a sand to be called well graded under the Indian Standard, it must have:

  5. Which clay mineral swells the most on wetting?

  6. In the Casagrande test, the liquid limit is the water content at which the groove closes over 13 mm in:

  7. The plasticity index of a soil is:

  8. A clay has wL = 60%, wP = 30% and natural water content 45%. Its liquidity index is:

  9. A clay has plasticity index 45% and clay-size content 30%. Its activity class is:

  10. A fine soil has wL = 40% and IP = 18%. Using the A-line, it is classified as:

  11. A soil is coarse-grained in the IS system when more than 50% of it by weight is:

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

When is a sand well graded?

A sand is well graded when Cu is more than 6 and Cc lies between 1 and 3. For gravel, Cu must be more than 4.

What is the plasticity index?

It is the liquid limit minus the plastic limit, the range of water content over which the soil behaves as a plastic material.

What does the A-line on the plasticity chart do?

It separates clays above the line from silts and organic soils below it. Its equation is Ip = 0.73(wL − 20).

What do the letters L, I and H mean in IS classification?

They show low, intermediate and high compressibility, for liquid limits below 35, from 35 to 50, and above 50.