TNPSC Group 1 course‹› 0:00 studied

TNPSC Group 1 · Module 1 · Mains depth · 23 min

Harappan Civilisation II: society, religion, script and decline

What TNPSC Group 1 asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Part A: General Studies · History and culture of India, and the Indian national movement.

TNPSC Group 1 questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.

Start from zero: who were the Harappans and what happened to them?

In the chapter on Harappan cities we saw how the cities were planned and how their economy worked. But a city is also people: rich and poor, priests and potters, families and strangers. This chapter asks who ruled them, what they believed and how they lived.

Answering is hard because we cannot read their script. Everything comes from objects: houses, graves, seals, figurines and the layout of towns. So historians must reason carefully, and you will meet many 'perhaps' and 'some scholars think'.

Then comes the great puzzle. Around 1900 BC, the cities shrank, the script and standard weights disappeared, and people moved away. Why did India's first urban civilisation end?

There is no single answer, and that is exactly why it is a favourite Mains question. You will learn the main theories, their limits and the view most historians hold today. You will also see that the Harappan way of life did not vanish; it was transformed.

Harappan society and its end at a glance

Theme What we know Key evidence
Polity An early state; one state or several city-states is debated Uniform weights, seals, script; planned towns
Society Socially varied: rich and poor, craft specialists House sizes, barracks, ornaments
Burials Little sign of hierarchy; cemeteries away from towns North-south burials; Lothal joint burials
Religion Varied local cults Mother goddess, 'Pashupati' seal, fire altars, Great Bath
Seals 2,000+, mostly square steatite Unicorn most common; no horse
Script About 400 signs, right to left, unread Seals, tablets, pottery
Decline Urban phase ends around 1900 BC Abandoned sites; seals and weights vanish
Afterwards Late Harappan rural cultures; migration east and south Cemetery H, Jhukar; doab sites; Daimabad

Keep one rule in mind: with an unread script, every interpretation is an inference. Good answers say so.

The Harappan story in one line

Who ruled? The debate on the Harappan state

Chiefdom or state? In a chiefdom, a chief has ritual authority and redistributes tribute, but kinship still governs most relations. In a state, rulers actually control resources and labour, and rules apply beyond kin groups. Which one fits the Harappans?

Who ruled? Three views

Signs of a state. Planned towns, drains and millions of fired bricks needed labour mobilised and supervised over long periods. Uniform weights, seals and script across a huge area point to central standards. Craft centres like Chanhudaro and outposts like Shortughai suggest someone organised production and exchange.

View 1: a chiefdom. W.F. Fairservis and J. Shaffer see the Harappan system as a chiefdom rather than a true state. They stress the absence of palaces, royal tombs and clear rulers. For them, the cities were large ritual and craft centres held together by kin-based leaders.

View 2: several city-states. S.P. Gupta, B.B. Lal and J.M. Kenoyer imagine several city-states, each centred on a big city: Mohenjodaro, Harappa, Rakhigarhi, Dholavira and Ganweriwala. They see regional identity and autonomy in each big centre. Critics say this projects the later city-states of the early historic period backwards.

View 3: a single state. J. Jacobson and Shereen Ratnagar argue for one state. Their reasons are the common material culture over a vast area, one script and one system of weights, a shared tool kit, and seal motifs like the unicorn that show no regional clusters. They also point to settlements founded for set purposes and to the uneven spread of big cities.

An early, unusual state. Even those who see a state agree it was unlike later ones. There were no coins, probably no markets in the modern sense, and no clear bureaucracy or standing army. Control may have rested mainly on labour mobilisation rather than taxes, and much of tribal and chiefdom society survived inside it.

Why there are no 'kings'. We find no palaces, no royal statues of the Egyptian kind and no rich royal tombs. This has led some to imagine priest-rulers or a council of merchants. With an unread script, such ideas remain guesses.

How to use the debate. In an exam, present the three views with their evidence and weaknesses. Then show why the 'early state' view, combining uniform standards with surviving kinship, explains most of the evidence. It also explains why society slipped back to tribal forms when the state collapsed.

How people lived: society, dress and death

A mixed city population. Cities brought together people who were not kin, so ties of residence and interdependence mattered more than in villages. Yet kin groups survived, as in Bronze Age Mesopotamia and China. Labour and resources may still have been organised along kin lines.

Seals, figurines and sculpture

Signs of inequality. House sizes varied from one-room units to large homes with many rooms. Near the Harappa granary stood rows of small quarters, often read as workmen's quarters, and Lothal had workshops and houses of coppersmiths and bead-makers. A rare 12 cm carnelian bead was copied in clay by those who could not afford it.

But not simple. Variation in house size may reflect family size, not only wealth. There is no neat link between big houses and rich objects. Rich and poor lived side by side in Mohenjodaro's lower town.

Occupations. The population included priests, warriors, peasants, traders and artisans such as masons, weavers, goldsmiths and potters. Some crafts needed full-time skill and special facilities, like metallurgy, bead-making and seal-cutting. But many 'specialists' may also have done some farming.

How the Harappans buried their dead

Dress and ornaments. Figurines show men in a garment wrapped round the lower body, with a cloth over the left shoulder, and women in a skirt-like garment. People wore cotton and wool, and spindle whorls and needles show spinning and sewing. Men and women both wore necklaces, armlets, earrings and bangles; the rich used gold, silver and semi-precious stones, the poor terracotta.

Was it matriarchal? The popularity of female figurines has led some to suggest that Harappan society gave women a high place, even that it was matriarchal. But without the script this cannot be tested. Treat it as a weak suggestion, not a fact.

Burials. The dead were mostly buried in cemeteries away from settlements. Bodies were usually laid north-south, head to the north, with pots and ornaments such as bangles, beads and copper mirrors, suggesting a belief in life after death. Burials were extended, in urns, in coffins, or symbolic.

The 'priest-king' bust, Mohenjodaro
The 'priest-king' bust, MohenjodaroPhoto: Mamoon Mengal, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Notable graves. Lothal has joint burials of a man and a woman. Kalibangan has a symbolic burial, with pots but no skeleton. These differences may reflect varied beliefs.

Equal in death? Harappan graves show little sign of hierarchy. There is nothing like the pyramids of Egypt or the Royal Cemetery of Ur, where some graves hold great wealth. Either the elite displayed status in other ways, or Harappan society hid inequality in death.

Seals as identity. More than 2,000 seals have been found, mostly square steatite with a pierced boss at the back, so they could be strung and worn. Each bears an animal or scene and a few signs of the script. They probably marked identity or authenticity in dealings with strangers, and sealings on packed goods at Lothal show their trade use.

A unicorn seal
A unicorn sealPhoto: Ismoon, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Seal motifs. The 'unicorn', a one-horned mythical animal, is the most common motif. Seals also show the bull, elephant, tiger and rhinoceros, but not the horse, which has fuelled debate on whether the Harappans knew it. No motif is concentrated in one region, a point used to argue for a single state.

Art in stone and clay. A stone bust of a bearded man with half-closed eyes and a patterned cloak over the left shoulder, from Mohenjodaro, is often called a 'priest'. Terracotta figurines of men, women and animals were common, and female ones outnumber male. Bronze work peaked in the 'dancing girl' described in the previous chapter.

Beliefs and the unread script

Reading religion from objects. With no texts, Harappan religion must be inferred from figurines, seals, buildings and burials. Interpretations often draw on later Indian religion. That is useful but risky, because it can read later ideas into older objects.

Clues to Harappan beliefs

Mother goddess. Many terracotta female figurines, some with fan-shaped headdresses, are read as mother goddesses. One seal shows a plant growing from a woman's body, probably an earth or fertility goddess. But such figurines are absent in Kutch, so this was not a universal cult.

The 'Pashupati' seal. A famous seal shows a horned figure seated in a yogic posture, surrounded by an elephant, tiger, rhinoceros and buffalo. John Marshall called it a proto-Shiva or Pashupati, 'lord of animals'. More recently some scholars read the same figure as evidence of shamanistic beliefs, so the identification is disputed.

Why the script is still unread

Trees and animals. One seal shows a horned deity between pipal branches with a kneeling worshipper, suggesting tree worship. Animals like the bull appear often, and animal worship seems to have been common. Narrative scenes on seals may depict rituals.

Fire altars. At Kalibangan and Lothal, brick platforms with pits of ash and animal bones are identified as fire altars. They are absent at Harappa and Mohenjodaro. So if there was a fire cult, it was limited to a few centres.

The 'Pashupati' seal
The 'Pashupati' sealPhoto: SpeakingArch, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Great Bath. The Great Bath at Mohenjodaro is often seen as the site of a public or royal ritual of purification by water. Ritual bathing on that scale may have been confined to Mohenjodaro. Some see links with later Indian ideas of ritual purity.

Linga and yoni? Some scholars identify certain stone objects as linga and yoni, but others doubt it. Treat such claims with caution. The overall picture is of many local cults under a broad shared culture, a 'great tradition' over many 'little traditions'.

A Harappan female figurine
A Harappan female figurinePhoto: Ismoon, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

The script. The Harappans were literate. Their script has about 400 signs, which is too many for an alphabet and suggests word-signs or pictorial signs. It was written from right to left, as shown by how signs crowd at the left edge.

Why we cannot read it. Most inscriptions are very short, a few signs on a seal. There is no bilingual inscription, like the Rosetta Stone that unlocked Egyptian hieroglyphs. The language behind it is unknown; some have suggested Brahui or other Dravidian links, but nothing is proven.

Who could read? Because writing appears mainly on seals and small objects used in exchange, literacy was probably limited to a few people, perhaps traders, officials or priests. Seals used in trade do not prove that ordinary people could read. Long-distance contacts may also have made some people bilingual.

The end of the cities

What changed around 1900 BC? Between about 1900 and 1800 BC the material record changes. Many settlements in the core areas of Sind, west Punjab and the Hakra valley are abandoned, and surveys along the Hakra show their number falling sharply in the Late Harappan period. Mesopotamian texts also stop mentioning Meluhha around this time.

Where people went after the cities

Signs of decline in the cities. In Mohenjodaro, Harappa and Kalibangan, building standards fell. Houses of old, reused bricks encroached on roads and streets, and entry points to the Great Bath were blocked until it and the granary fell out of use. The cities were turning into slums, with fewer figurines, beads and inlay work in the late levels.

The hallmarks vanish. The typical Harappan objects disappear: cubical weights, long and etched carnelian beads, square steatite seals and the script. Fewer raw materials were used, and most were local. Town planning and uniform pottery also faded.

Theory 1: floods and earthquakes. Mohenjodaro was rebuilt at least three times over layers of silt. The hydrologist R.L. Raikes argued that earthquakes raised land in the lower Indus, damming the river into a lake that drowned the city. H.T. Lambrick replied that the Indus would easily breach such a dam, and that the 'silt' may be wind-blown; at best the theory explains one region.

Theory 1b: the river moved. Lambrick's own view was that the unstable Indus shifted its course away from Mohenjodaro, starving the city and its villages of water. But people used to such shifts could simply have built a new city. It explains the desertion of Mohenjodaro, not the end of a civilisation.

Theory 2: drying and climate. D.P. Agrawal and Sood stressed growing aridity and the drying of the Ghaggar-Hakra after the Sutlej was captured by the Indus and the Yamuna shifted east to the Ganga. This explains the desertion of sites in the Cholistan desert. But the drying has not been firmly dated, and it would not explain abandonment in Sind or Gujarat.

Why did the cities decline? Theories tested

Theory 3: Aryan invasion. Mortimer Wheeler blamed invading Aryans. He cited skeletons lying in Mohenjodaro's late streets, Indra's title Purandara ('destroyer of forts') and a Rig Vedic battle at Hariyupiya on the Ravi, a name like Harappa. The theory has long been rejected: the decline is dated before the Vedic people arrived, the cities were already decaying, and there is no evidence of a military assault.

Theory 4: ecological strain. W.A. Fairservis calculated that a city like Mohenjodaro needed food from very many villages. He argued that growing numbers of people and cattle wore out the forests, pasture and fuel of a fragile semi-arid land, bringing more floods and droughts and pushing people towards Gujarat and the east. Critics note that the soils stayed fertile and that his numbers rest on scanty data.

Theory 5: a crisis of the state. Most historians now see no single cause. Environmental stress, changing rivers and loss of trade may have combined with inherent weaknesses in the socio-political structure. Around 1900 BC the Harappan state seems to have collapsed or entered a crisis, leading to widespread desertion and migration.

Where did people go? People moved to outlying areas: Kathiawar in Gujarat, eastern Punjab, Haryana and the upper Ganga-Yamuna doab. A 1984 list counts 31 Mature Harappan but 130 Late Harappan sites in the doab, and in Gujarat about 13 Mature Harappan settlements gave way to 200 or more. Such growth in a few generations can only mean migration: a shift of population, not its disappearance.

Late Harappan cultures. In the Indus valley, the Cemetery H culture (near Harappa) and the Jhukar culture took over as smaller, mostly rural settlements. Cemetery H people, known from their burials and distinct pottery, appeared at Harappa before it was abandoned; at Jhukar and Chanhudaro people still lived in brick houses but gave up the planned layout, and used circular stamp seals and metal objects with Iranian parallels.

What vanished and what carried on

In Kutch and Saurashtra, Rangpur even grew more prosperous, using Lustrous Red Ware. In Maharashtra, Daimabad had a Late Harappan phase with 4:2:1 bricks and script signs on pottery.

Mixing with local cultures. Migrating Harappan groups joined local cultural sequences. In the doab they mixed with the Ochre Coloured Pottery culture, and in Maharashtra with the Savalda and Chalcolithic cultures described in the Stone Age and Chalcolithic chapter. Harappan traditions thus flowed into the wider Indian village world.

Transformation, not collapse. What disappeared were the state, urban life, writing and long-distance trade. Farming, herding, crafts and basic technologies continued.

That is why historians speak of decline and transformation rather than a sudden end. Since the late 1960s, scholars such as Malik and Possehl have studied these continuities instead of hunting for a single cause.

Mains lens: what the end tells us about the beginning

A clue in the collapse. When the Harappan state fell, society did not keep its urban institutions. It reverted to tribal and chiefdom forms. That tells us something about what the state had been all along.

Kinship never left. The quick reversal suggests that kin groups kept their importance even inside the cities. The institutions created to bind strangers and distant settlements, such as standard weights, seals and script, never took deep root in society. They depended on the state and fell with it.

A 'great tradition' over 'little traditions'. Harappan cohesion may have come from a common code imposed from above, a great tradition covering many local cultures. When the top layer broke, the little traditions continued. That explains both the uniformity at its height and the diversity after it.

Legacy. Some later Indian practices may echo Harappan ones: the cults of the mother goddess and Pashupati, sacred trees, rivers and animals, attention to bathing, a weight system based on 16, and bullock carts and boats. Fire altars at Kalibangan and Lothal have even led some to ask whether Vedic priests learnt fire rituals from Harappan ones.

But direct continuity is hard to prove without the script. India's next cities, in the Ganga plain from about 600 BC, grew from a different base.

How to write it. Describe the evidence of decline first, then evaluate each theory against its geographical reach. Reject the invasion theory with reasons, and present the multi-causal 'crisis of the state' view. End with continuity: migration, Late Harappan cultures and the spread of Harappan traits into village India.

Mains practice: Harappan society and decline

Angle Question Key points to cover
Polity "Was the Harappan civilisation ruled by a single state?" Evaluate the evidence. Chiefdom view (Fairservis, Shaffer); city-states (Gupta, Lal, Kenoyer); single state (Jacobson, Ratnagar); uniform weights, script, seals; labour; no coins, army or palaces; early state.
Religion "Harappan religion was plural rather than uniform." Discuss. Mother goddess (not in Kutch); Pashupati vs shaman; tree and animal worship; fire altars only at Kalibangan, Lothal; Great Bath; burials; risk of reading later religion back.
Decline "The Harappan civilisation declined; it did not die." Examine the causes and consequences of its decline. Evidence c. 1900-1800 BC; Hakra sites fall; Raikes floods, Lambrick river shift, Agrawal aridity, Wheeler invasion (rejected), Fairservis ecology, state crisis; migration; Cemetery H, Jhukar, Daimabad; doab 31 to 130; reversion to tribal forms.

These are practice questions written by us, not past papers. Past questions from your exam appear in the PYQ panel.

How to use this table: each answer should explain the what, then the why, and end with what it led to.

Quick revision

  • State debate: chiefdom (Fairservis, Shaffer); city-states (S.P. Gupta, B.B. Lal, Kenoyer); single state (Jacobson, Ratnagar). No coins, bureaucracy or standing army.
  • Society: varied houses; barracks near Harappa granary; priests, warriors, peasants, traders, artisans; cotton and wool.
  • Burials: cemeteries away from towns; north-south, head north; little hierarchy; Lothal joint burials; Kalibangan symbolic burial.
  • Seals: 2,000+, square steatite, pierced boss; unicorn most common; bull, elephant, tiger, rhino; no horse.
  • Religion: mother goddess (not in Kutch); 'Pashupati'/proto-Shiva seal (elephant, tiger, rhino, buffalo; shaman reading); pipal deity; fire altars at Kalibangan and Lothal (not Harappa, Mohenjodaro); Great Bath.
  • Bearded 'priest' bust (Mohenjodaro).
  • Script: about 400 signs, right to left, undeciphered; short texts, no bilingual; literacy limited.
  • Decline c. 1900-1800 BC: Hakra sites fall sharply; Meluhha vanishes from Mesopotamian texts; weights, seals, beads, script vanish; Great Bath disused.
  • Theories: Raikes earthquake-floods; Lambrick Indus shift; Agrawal and Sood aridity, Ghaggar drying; Wheeler Aryan invasion (Purandara, Hariyupiya; rejected); Fairservis ecological strain; state crisis.
  • Continuity: Gujarat 13 → 200+ sites; Rangpur (Lustrous Red Ware); Malik and Possehl.
  • Late Harappan: Cemetery H, Jhukar; Kathiawar, east Punjab, Haryana, doab (31 → 130); Daimabad 4:2:1 bricks and script; mixing with OCP.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 11 answered

  1. Fire altars have been found at which pair of Harappan sites?

  2. Which animal is the most common motif on Harappan seals?

  3. The animals around the seated figure on the so-called 'Pashupati' seal are:

  4. Consider the following statements about the Harappan script: 1. It has about 400 signs. 2. It was written from right to left. 3. It was deciphered with the help of a bilingual inscription. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  5. A symbolic burial, with pots but no skeleton, has been found at:

  6. Which scholar argued that the Harappan civilisation was a single state?

  7. Consider the following statements about the end of the Mature Harappan phase: 1. Cubical weights and square steatite seals disappeared. 2. Many sites in the Hakra valley were abandoned. 3. The script came into wider use in the Late Harappan phase. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  8. Cemetery H and Jhukar are names of:

  9. Which site in Maharashtra had a Late Harappan phase with bricks in the 4:2:1 ratio?

  10. Assertion (A): The drying of the Ghaggar-Hakra cannot alone explain the Harappan decline. Reason (R): It explains the desertion of Cholistan sites but not the abandonment of other regions.

  11. Assertion (A): The Harappan cities declined around 1900 BC. Reason (R): Archaeology shows a large-scale massacre by invading Aryans at Mohenjodaro.

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. "The Harappan civilisation declined; it did not die." Examine the causes and consequences of its decline. (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Evidence c. 1900-1800 BC: core sites abandoned, Hakra sites fall sharply, weights, seals, beads, script vanish
    • Raikes floods, Lambrick river shift (Mohenjodaro only); Agrawal-Sood aridity (Cholistan only); Fairservis ecology
    • Aryan invasion rejected: no massacre evidence, chronology
    • Crisis of the early state; multi-causal view
    • Migration to Kathiawar, east Punjab, Haryana, doab (31 to 130 sites)
    • Late Harappan: Cemetery H, Jhukar, Daimabad; mixing with OCP
    • Continuity of farming, herding, crafts; reversion to tribal and chiefdom forms
    • Conclusion: transformation, not collapse

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

Has the Harappan script been deciphered?

No. It has about 400 signs, was written mostly from right to left, and the inscriptions are too short to decipher reliably.

What is the Pashupati seal?

A seal from Mohenjodaro showing a horned figure seated in a yogic pose surrounded by animals, which John Marshall called proto-Shiva.

Why did the Harappan cities decline?

No single cause is accepted. Theories include drier climate, the drying of the Ghaggar-Hakra, floods, tectonic shifts, over-use of land and the end of trade with Mesopotamia.

Did the Harappans use iron?

No. The Harappans were a Bronze Age people who used copper and bronze along with stone; iron came later.