UPSC CSE · Module 35 · Mains depth · 16 min
Members and the health of Parliament: privileges, defection, committees and decline
What UPSC CSE asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims Paper I: General Studies · Indian Polity and Governance-Constitution, Political System, Panchayati Raj, Public Policy, Rights Issues, etc.
- Mains Paper III: General Studies II (Governance, Constitution, polity, social justice, IR) · Separation of powers between various organs dispute redressal mechanisms and institutions.
- Mains Paper III: General Studies II (Governance, Constitution, polity, social justice, IR) · Parliament and State legislatures—structure, functioning, conduct of business, powers & privileges and issues arising out of these.
- Mains Paper III: General Studies II (Governance, Constitution, polity, social justice, IR) · Structure, organization and functioning of the Executive and the Judiciary—Ministries and Departments of the Government; pressure groups and formal/informal associations and their role in the Polity.
UPSC CSE has asked 11 questions from this chapter (2026, 2025, 2024, 2023, 2021, 2019); 24 from its whole module.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: what keeps Parliament healthy?
Imagine a school council where students raise complaints about the canteen. If a student could be punished by the principal for speaking up, nobody would speak. If members could switch sides for a reward, no decision would last. If the council had to check every bill in one big noisy meeting, nothing would get checked properly.
Parliament faces the same three problems. Parliament answers them with privileges that protect free speech, the anti-defection law that stops members from switching sides at will, and committees that do the detailed work in small groups.
This chapter explains these three tools. It then asks a harder question: has Parliament grown weaker compared with the executive, and what can be done about it?
Parliamentary privileges
What they are. Privileges are special rights that let members and the Houses do their work freely and without fear. They belong to the House as a whole and to members as individuals. They are not personal favours, but protections for the job of representing the people.
Enumerated privileges. These are spelt out, and the main ones are:
- Freedom of speech in each House.
- Immunity from court proceedings for anything said or any vote given in Parliament or its committees.
- Immunity for publications made by or under the authority of a House, such as reports, papers and proceedings.
- Freedom from arrest in civil cases during a session and for 40 days before and after it.
- Exemption from attending as a witness in a court while the House is sitting.
Unenumerated privileges. Beyond the listed ones, the Houses have privileges similar to those of the British House of Commons. The most important is the power to punish for contempt. Like the Commons, Parliament can punish any person, member or not, who commits contempt of the House.
Why free speech in the House matters. A member may need to expose a scam, criticise a powerful person or raise an uncomfortable fact. If every such statement could lead to a defamation case, members would stay silent. The privilege ensures that what is said in the House is answerable to the House, not to the courts.
Breach of privilege and contempt of the House
The two terms are close but not the same, and examiners like to test the difference.
| Term | Meaning | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Breach of privilege | Disregard of a specific privilege, right or immunity of a member or a House | Obstructing a member on the way to the House |
| Contempt of the House | Disobeying the House's authority or misconduct before it or its committees | Interrupting proceedings, a witness refusing the oath, false evidence, forged documents |
The relationship. Every breach of privilege can be treated as a contempt, but a contempt need not involve any listed privilege. Contempt is the wider idea, because it covers any act that obstructs the House in doing its work.
How the House acts. A member can raise a question of privilege, and the presiding officer decides whether it may be taken up. The House can examine the matter and punish the person concerned, for example with a reprimand.
Defection and the anti-defection law
What defection means. Defection, also called crossing the floor, means a member changing allegiance from one party to another. Voters usually elect a candidate because of the party ticket. So when a member switches sides after the election, the voters' choice is overturned without their consent.
Why a law was needed. During the fourth Lok Sabha (1967-70), defections and party splits became common in Parliament and especially in the States. Governments rose and fell as members changed sides, sometimes more than once. This instability built a strong case for a law against defection.
The law. In the eighth Lok Sabha (1985-89), Parliament passed a constitutional amendment providing for disqualification of members on the ground of defection. The provisions are in the Tenth Schedule, read with Article 102(2) for Parliament and Article 191(2) for State Legislatures. A member who defects loses the seat.
The debate it raised. The law brought stability, but it also tied members tightly to the party whip. Critics argue that a member can no longer vote freely on a matter of conscience. Others point out that the law has not fully stopped defections, because groups of members still find ways to change sides.
Parliamentary committees: the House in miniature
Why committees. Parliament is supposed to keep a close watch on the government. But the full House has too little time and too many members to study complex administration and accounts in detail. So it creates committees, smaller groups of members that can study a subject closely and report back.
Four families of committees.
| Group | Purpose | Example |
|---|---|---|
| House organisation | Deal with the House's own rules and powers | Rules Committee |
| Law-making | Study Bills in detail | Select committees |
| Accountability | Make departments answerable | Department-related Standing Committees |
| Money | Watch over public spending | PAC, Estimates Committee |
Standing and ad hoc. A standing committee is permanent. It is constituted every year or from time to time, by election by the House or by nomination by the presiding officer. An ad hoc committee is set up for a specific task and ends when that task is done.
How they are kept fair. Seats on a committee are shared in proportion to party strength in the House. A Minister in charge of a Bill before a committee does not take part in its deliberations, which limits the influence of the executive.
Why they work. Committees meet away from cameras, so members can discuss sensitive matters in a less partisan way. They can call officials and experts and examine records. By convention, Ministries report on the action taken on the recommendations of the financial committees, which gives those reports real weight.
The opposition and the record of the Lok Sabha
The opposition's role. In a parliamentary democracy, the opposition is expected to act as an alternative government. It usually loses when votes are counted. But its speeches reach the whole country and are heard inside the ruling party too, so it can shape policy indirectly.
Leader of the Opposition. In the Rajya Sabha, the Leader of the Opposition is the leader of the largest opposition party, recognised as such by the Chairman. If two opposition parties are equal in strength, the Chairman recognises one of their leaders, and that decision is final.
A glance at history.
- The second Lok Sabha (1957-62) is often called a golden period. It passed many laws, two Private Members' Bills became law, and a joint sitting settled the Dowry Prohibition Bill.
- In the same House, the Mundhra affair showed how Question Hour could hold the government to account.
- The fourth Lok Sabha (1967-70) saw defections and party splits.
- The eighth Lok Sabha (1985-89) passed the anti-defection amendment and the amendment lowering the voting age from 21 to 18.
Is Parliament sovereign? Parliament and the courts
The British idea. In Britain, Parliament is sovereign: it can make or unmake any law, and no court can set it aside. India borrowed the parliamentary system, but not this idea in full. Indian Parliament works within a written Constitution, and the courts can review its laws.
The long tussle over amending power.
| Year | Event | What it said |
|---|---|---|
| 1967 | Golaknath case | By 6:5, Parliament cannot amend Fundamental Rights |
| 1971 | 24th Amendment | Parliament reasserted its power; an amendment is not 'law' under Article 13 |
| 1973 | Kesavananda Bharati case | Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights but cannot alter the basic structure |
| 1976 | 42nd Amendment | Declared Parliament's amending power unlimited and beyond court review |
| 1980 | Minerva Mills case | Struck down clauses (4) and (5) of Article 368, as judicial review is a basic feature |
Two views. Supporters of parliamentary supremacy argue that Parliament, elected by all adults, speaks for the people, while "basic structure" is not written anywhere in the Constitution. The other side argues that if Parliament could amend anything without court review, the Constitution would be at the mercy of a passing majority. The settled position today is a balance: Parliament has wide power, but within the basic structure.
Why these rules exist
Each tool in this chapter answers a specific danger to a representative House. Read the table as "danger, then answer".
| Tool | Danger it answers | Cost or limit |
|---|---|---|
| Free speech in the House | Members silenced by fear of lawsuits | Can be misused to make unfair attacks |
| Power to punish contempt | Outsiders obstructing the House | The House acts as judge in its own cause |
| Anti-defection law | Governments toppled by members switching sides | Less freedom for conscience votes |
| Committees | No time for detailed scrutiny on the floor | Reports are advisory and often not debated |
| Judicial review and basic structure | A passing majority rewriting the Constitution | Tension between elected Parliament and unelected judges |
The pattern. Every protection has a price. Good answers in the exam show both the reason for a rule and its cost, and then suggest how the balance can be improved.
Mains lens: the decline of Parliament
A common question: "In theory the legislature controls the executive; in practice power has passed to the executive." Discuss with reference to the Indian Parliament.
Reasons given for the decline:
- Lack of time and delegated legislation. Parliament can lay down only broad policy, so Bills leave the details to rules made by the government. This delegated legislation shifts real law-making power to the executive.
- Party dominance and the whip. When one party has a large majority and members must follow the whip, debate cannot change outcomes.
- Defections and corruption lowered public respect for the institution.
- A weak opposition and weak public opinion reduce the pressure on the government.
- In practice, the executive headed by the Prime Minister sets the agenda of the House.
The other side:
- Question Hour, adjournment motions and committees still expose failures, as the Mundhra affair showed in the 1950s.
- Committees, especially the financial ones, work in a non-partisan way and Ministries must report action taken.
- The opposition's arguments reach the country and shape policy even when outvoted.
Way forward: more sittings and less disruption, sending more Bills to committees, debating committee reports in the House, closer scrutiny of rules made under delegated powers, and stronger research support for members. A balanced answer concludes that Parliament's tools are intact, but its effectiveness depends on the will of members to use them.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.
1. Concept: What are parliamentary privileges? Why are they needed, and what concerns do they raise?
- Define privileges and give the enumerated list, including the 40-day civil arrest rule.
- Explain the unenumerated privileges and the power to punish contempt.
- Give the purpose: free and fearless representation.
- Note the concerns: the House judging its own cause and possible misuse.
2. Evaluation: "The anti-defection law has brought stability at the cost of the independence of legislators." Discuss.
- Explain defection and the instability of the late 1960s.
- Describe the Tenth Schedule with Articles 102(2) and 191(2).
- Weigh stability against the loss of conscience votes and the continued group defections.
- Suggest a possible balance, such as applying the whip only to votes that decide whether the government survives.
3. Analysis: "Parliament in India is supreme but not sovereign." Explain with reference to judicial decisions.
- Contrast British parliamentary sovereignty with India's written Constitution.
- Trace Golaknath, the 24th Amendment, Kesavananda, the 42nd Amendment and Minerva Mills.
- Present both views on the basic structure doctrine.
- Conclude with the balance of wide power within the basic structure.
Quick revision
- Privileges are enumerated and unenumerated; the enumerated ones include free speech, immunity for words and votes, protected publications, freedom from civil arrest (session plus 40 days before and after) and exemption from being a witness.
- Parliament can punish anyone, member or not, for contempt; contempt is wider than breach of privilege.
- Defection leads to disqualification under the Tenth Schedule with Articles 102(2) and 191(2), added in the eighth Lok Sabha after the defections of the late 1960s.
- Committees fall into four families: House organisation, law-making, accountability and money.
- Standing committees are permanent; ad hoc committees end with their task.
- In the Rajya Sabha, the Chairman recognises the Leader of the Opposition, and that decision is final.
- Indian Parliament is supreme but not sovereign: Golaknath 1967, Kesavananda 1973 (basic structure), Minerva Mills 1980.
- Decline: delegated legislation, party dominance, defections, weak opposition.
UPSC CSE questions from this chapter
Consider the following statements about the Committee on the Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes of the Parliament of India : 1. Although members of this Committee are elected from both Houses of Parliament, the Chairperson of this Committee is appointed by the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha. 2. Twenty members are elected by the Rajya Sabha and ten members by the Lok Sabha. 3. No Minister, except for the Union Minister of Social Justice and Empowerment, is eligible to be a member of this Committee. 4. Members are elected for a fixed term of two years from the date they enter their office. Which one of the following conclusions based on the above statements is correct ?
- (a) There are four correct statements.
- (b) There is only one correct statement, that is statement 2.
- (c) There are two correct statements, that include statement 1.
- (d) There is no correct statement.
Show answer
(d) There is no correct statement. · our answer; official key awaited
Examine whether the constitutional office of the Lok Sabha Speaker has become vulnerable to partisan politics under the current anti-defection regime. What institutional changes are required to ensure the neutrality of the Lok Sabha Speaker in managing a polarised House?
Consider the following statements : I. If any question arises as to whether a Member of the House of the People has become subject to disqualification under the 10th Schedule, the President's decision in accordance with the opinion of the Council of Union Ministers shall be final. II. There is no mention of the word 'political party' in the Constitution of India. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) I only
- (b) II only
- (c) Both I and II
- (d) Neither I nor II
Show answer
(d) Neither I nor II · our answer; official key awaited
"The growth of cabinet system has practically resulted in the marginalisation of the parliamentary supremacy." Elucidate.
Explain the structure of the Parliamentary Committee system. How far have the financial committees helped in the institutionalisation of Indian Parliament ?
To what extent, in your view, the Parliament is able to ensure accountability of the executive in India?
In India, which of the following review the independent regulators in sectors like telecommunications, insurance, electricity, etc.? 1. Ad Hoc Committees set up by the Parliament 2. Parliamentary Department Related Standing Committees 3. Finance Commission 4. Financial Sector Legislative Reforms Commission 5. NITI Aayog Select the correct answer using the code given below.
- (a) 1 and 2
- (b) 1, 3 and 4
- (c) 3, 4 and 5
- (d) 2 and 5
Show answer
(a) 1 and 2 · our answer; official key awaited
Individual Parliamentarian's role as the national law maker is on a decline, which in turn, has adversely impacted the quality of debates and their outcome. Discuss.
Consider the following statements : 1. In the first Lok Sabha, the single largest party in the opposition was the Swatantra Party. 2. In the Lok Sabha, a "Leader of the Opposition" was recognised for the first time in 1969. 3. In the Lok Sabha, if a party does not have a minimum of 75 members, its leader cannot be recognised as the Leader of the Opposition. Which of the statements given above is/are correct ?
- (a) 1 and 3 only
- (b) 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
(b) 2 only · our answer; official key awaited
With reference to the Parliament of India, which of the following Parliamentary Committees scrutinizes and reports to the House whether the powers to make regulations, rules, sub-rules, by-laws, etc. conferred by the Constitution or delegated by the Parliament are being properly exercised by the Executive within the scope of such delegation ?
- (a) Committee on Government Assurances
- (b) Committee on Subordinate Legislation
- (c) Rules Committee
- (d) Business Advisory Committee
Show answer
(b) Committee on Subordinate Legislation · our answer; official key awaited
Why do you think the committees are considered to be useful for parliamentary work? Discuss, in this context, the role of the Estimates Committee.