UPSC CSE · Module 36 · Mains depth · 15 min
The Supreme Court: its origins, its judges and their independence
What UPSC CSE asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims Paper I: General Studies · Indian Polity and Governance-Constitution, Political System, Panchayati Raj, Public Policy, Rights Issues, etc.
- Mains Paper III: General Studies II (Governance, Constitution, polity, social justice, IR) · Separation of powers between various organs dispute redressal mechanisms and institutions.
- Mains Paper III: General Studies II (Governance, Constitution, polity, social justice, IR) · Parliament and State legislatures—structure, functioning, conduct of business, powers & privileges and issues arising out of these.
- Mains Paper III: General Studies II (Governance, Constitution, polity, social justice, IR) · Structure, organization and functioning of the Executive and the Judiciary—Ministries and Departments of the Government; pressure groups and formal/informal associations and their role in the Polity.
UPSC CSE has asked 4 questions from this chapter (2025, 2023, 2021, 2019); 17 from its whole module.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: why do we need an umpire?
Think of a cricket match. Two teams play hard, and each wants to win. If one team's captain could also decide who is out, the other team would never trust the result. So the game needs an umpire who belongs to neither side.
A country needs an umpire too. The government makes and carries out rules, and citizens, companies and States often disagree with it. Someone must decide, fairly and finally, what the law and the Constitution mean. In India that umpire is the judiciary, with the Supreme Court at the top.
An umpire is useful only if both sides trust it. That is why so much of this chapter is about independence: who chooses the judges, how long they stay, and how hard it is to remove them.
How the Supreme Court came to be
India's courts did not appear overnight. They grew over nearly two centuries of British rule, and each stage added a piece of today's system.
- 1773, Regulating Act. The first Supreme Court in India was set up at Calcutta, with a Chief Justice and three judges. It was a King's court, not a Company court. Supreme Courts later came up at Madras and Bombay.
- Two parallel systems. The Supreme Courts in the presidency towns followed English law, while the Sadr courts in the provinces followed regulations and personal laws.
- 1861, High Courts Act. The two systems were merged. High Courts replaced the Supreme Courts and the Sadr courts in Calcutta, Bombay and Madras. The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London remained the highest court of appeal.
- 1935 Act, Federal Court. The Federal Court was set up at Delhi to settle disputes about the federal Constitution and hear certain appeals. It worked until 26 January 1950.
- 1950, Supreme Court of India. The Supreme Court came into existence on 26 January 1950 and was inaugurated on 28 January 1950 in the Chamber of Princes of the old Parliament building, where the Federal Court had sat. It moved to its present building in 1958.
Why this history matters. Independent India did not start from scratch. It kept a single, unified court system built in colonial times, but made the Supreme Court the final court of appeal, so no appeal goes abroad any more.
Who sits on the Supreme Court?
Strength. The Constitution began with a Chief Justice and 7 other judges, eight in all. As cases grew, Parliament raised the number by law:
| Year | Total judges |
|---|---|
| 1950 | 8 |
| 1956 | 11 |
| 1960 | 14 |
| 1978 | 18 |
| 1986 | 26 |
| 2009 | 31 |
| 2019 | 34 |
Today the Court has the Chief Justice of India and not more than 33 other judges. Parliament can change this number by an ordinary law, without amending the Constitution.
Qualifications. A person can be appointed a judge if they are a citizen of India and meet any one of these:
- has been a High Court judge for at least 5 years; or
- has been a High Court advocate for at least 10 years; or
- is, in the President's opinion, a distinguished jurist.
Tenure. A Supreme Court judge holds office until the age of 65. A judge may resign earlier, or be removed by the special procedure explained below.
Who chooses the judges? From consultation to collegium
What the Constitution says. Under Article 124, the President appoints Supreme Court judges after consulting such judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts as needed. For any judge other than the Chief Justice, the Chief Justice of India must be consulted. The President acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers, so the text seems to give the government a strong role.
How the judges took the lead. Through judgments in the 1990s, the Supreme Court read "consultation" to give the judges the decisive voice.
- Second Judges case (6 October 1993): the Court held that the opinion of the judiciary, through the Chief Justice and senior judges, should prevail in appointments.
- Third Judges case (28 October 1998): an advisory opinion to the President that spelt out how the senior judges should decide together.
- A Memorandum of Procedure was prepared in 1998 on this basis. Proposals for the Supreme Court are initiated by the Chief Justice of India, and for a High Court by its Chief Justice with the two senior-most judges there.
This system, where senior judges recommend names, is called the collegium, popularly described as "judges selecting judges".
The NJAC attempt. In 2014, Parliament passed the Ninety-ninth Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, which came into force on 13 April 2015. The NJAC would have included judges, the Law Minister and eminent persons. On 16 October 2015, the Supreme Court declared both laws unconstitutional and void, holding that they threatened judicial independence. The collegium system became operative again, and the Court asked for the Memorandum of Procedure to be supplemented.
Removing a judge: hard by design
The procedure. A Supreme Court judge can be removed only on two grounds: proved misbehaviour or incapacity. Each House of Parliament must pass an address supported by:
- a majority of its total membership, and
- not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting.
The address is then presented to the President, who orders the removal. The process is often loosely called impeachment.
Why it is so hard. If a government could remove a judge with a simple majority, judges might hesitate to rule against it. A special majority in both Houses means that removal needs broad agreement across parties, not just the ruling side.
The Ramaswami case. Justice V. Ramaswami was the first Supreme Court judge against whom removal proceedings were started. A committee of judges found that he had misused his position while he was Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. Yet the motion failed in the Lok Sabha in May 1993, because many members abstained and the special majority was not reached.
The shields of independence
The Constitution surrounds judges with several protections. Each one closes a door through which the government or Parliament could pressure them.
| Protection | What it says | Pressure it blocks |
|---|---|---|
| Security of tenure | Serve till 65; removal only by special majority | Threat of dismissal |
| Protected salary | Cannot be cut to their disadvantage except in a Financial Emergency | Punishment through pay |
| Charged expenditure | Salaries and the Court's expenses charged on the Consolidated Fund | Yearly vote used as leverage |
| No discussion of conduct | Parliament cannot discuss a judge's conduct except on a removal motion | Political attacks in the House |
| Contempt power | Court can punish those who impute motives to judges | Campaigns to discredit judges |
A part of the basic structure. The Supreme Court has held that the independence of the judiciary is part of the basic structure of the Constitution. This means even a constitutional amendment cannot destroy it, which is why the NJAC laws were struck down.
Why independence matters beyond the courtroom. The Supreme Court's decisions bind all courts in India. If the top court were under the government's thumb, every citizen's rights would depend on the goodwill of those in power.
Why the system is built this way
| Feature | Why it was chosen | Concern it raises |
|---|---|---|
| President appoints after consulting judges | Balance between elected government and judicial expertise | Who has the final word? |
| Collegium | Keep appointments free from political pressure | Lack of transparency and accountability |
| Special majority for removal | Protect judges from a hostile majority | Removal almost never succeeds |
| Strength fixed by ordinary law | Flexibility as cases grow | Number alone cannot cure delays |
| Charged salaries | No yearly vote that could be used as a threat | None serious; widely accepted |
The central tension. Every design choice balances two values. Independence keeps judges free from pressure, while accountability ensures that their power is used well. Too much of either weakens the umpire.
Mains lens: collegium versus commission
A common question: "The collegium system protects judicial independence but lacks transparency." Critically examine in the light of the NJAC judgment.
In favour of the collegium:
- It keeps appointments away from the government, which is the biggest litigant before the courts.
- The Supreme Court has held that judicial independence is part of the basic structure, and the collegium is one way to protect it.
- Senior judges know the work and record of candidates better than anyone else.
Concerns about the collegium:
- Decisions are taken by a small group with little public reasoning, so it is hard to know why one person was chosen over another.
- There is no written constitutional basis; the system comes from judgments.
- Vacancies remain unfilled for long periods, adding to delays.
- Critics call it "judges selecting judges", with no outside check.
Why NJAC was struck down, and what next. The Court held that giving the executive and outsiders a decisive role in appointments threatened judicial independence. At the same time, it asked for the Memorandum of Procedure to be improved. A balanced answer suggests reforms within the collegium, such as clear eligibility criteria, a secretariat, published reasons and fixed timelines, so that independence and transparency move together.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.
1. History: Trace the evolution of the higher judiciary in India from 1773 to 1950.
- Regulating Act 1773 and the Calcutta Supreme Court.
- Parallel Supreme Courts and Sadr courts, merged by the High Courts Act 1861.
- The Privy Council as the final court of appeal, and the Federal Court under the 1935 Act.
- The Supreme Court from 26 January 1950, ending appeals abroad.
2. Analysis: How does the Constitution secure the independence of Supreme Court judges?
- Security of tenure to 65 and removal only by special majority in both Houses.
- Salaries protected and charged on the Consolidated Fund.
- No discussion of conduct in Parliament; contempt power.
- Independence as part of the basic structure; the NJAC judgment.
3. Evaluation: "The removal procedure for judges is so difficult that it has become ineffective." Discuss.
- Explain the grounds and the special majority.
- Use the Ramaswami case to show how abstentions defeated a motion.
- Argue why difficulty protects judges from political misuse.
- Suggest other ways of accountability, such as in-house inquiries and transparency, without weakening tenure.
Quick revision
- 1773 Regulating Act: Calcutta Supreme Court. 1861: High Courts. 1935 Act: Federal Court at Delhi.
- Supreme Court came into existence on 26 January 1950 and was inaugurated on 28 January 1950.
- Strength: began with 8; now 34 (Chief Justice plus up to 33), changed by Parliament through ordinary law.
- Qualifications: citizen, plus 5 years as High Court judge, or 10 years as High Court advocate, or distinguished jurist; retire at 65.
- Collegium: Second Judges case 1993, Third Judges case 1998, Memorandum of Procedure 1998.
- NJAC: 99th Amendment 2014, in force 13 April 2015, struck down 16 October 2015.
- Removal: proved misbehaviour or incapacity; majority of total membership and two-thirds present and voting, in each House.
- Salaries charged on the Consolidated Fund; cannot be cut except in a Financial Emergency.
UPSC CSE questions from this chapter
Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.
"Constitutionally guaranteed judicial independence is a prerequisite of democracy." Comment.
Discuss the desirability of greater representation to women in the higher judiciary to ensure diversity, equity and inclusiveness.
Consider the following statements : 1. The motion to impeach a Judge of the Supreme Court of India cannot be rejected by the Speaker of the Lok Sabha as per the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968. 2. The Constitution of India defines and gives details of what constitutes 'incapacity and proved misbehaviour' of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India. 3. The details of the process of impeachment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India are given in the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968. 4. If the motion for the impeachment of a Judge is taken up for voting, the law requires the motion to be backed by each House of the Parliament and supported by a majority of total membership of that House and by not less than two-thirds of total members of that House present and voting. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2
- (b) 3 only
- (c) 3 and 4 only
- (d) 1, 3 and 4
Show answer
(c) 3 and 4 only · our answer; official key awaited