International Relations‹› 0:00 studied

Module 1 · 14 min read · Free chapter

Who makes foreign policy: PM, MEA, NSC, Parliament, treaty power and the states

In short

Foreign affairs are in the Union List, so the Centre controls them. The executive power under Article 73 lets the government sign treaties without Parliament's approval, while Article 253 lets Parliament make laws to implement them. In practice the Prime Minister's Office, the Ministry of External Affairs and the National Security Council lead, with Parliament's committees and border states also influencing policy.

What are you preparing for? We show the practice and previous year questions of your exam.

Start from zero: who decides for the family?

Think of a joint family. When a relative from another town asks for a loan, or a neighbour proposes a shared wall, somebody has to decide. Usually the head of the family has the final word, but an elder sibling handles the relatives, a cousin who knows the neighbours gives advice, and the grandparents remind everyone of old promises.

Who decides for the family?

A country works in a similar way. Someone must decide whom to befriend, what deals to sign and how to respond when a neighbour causes trouble. But no single person does it alone: there are leaders who decide, specialists who negotiate, advisers who warn and representatives who question.

This chapter answers a simple question: who makes India's foreign policy, and under what rules? It starts with the Constitution, then moves to the Prime Minister, the security system, the Ministry of External Affairs, Parliament and the states.

The answer matters for the exam and for democracy. A policy that is made well has clear ownership, good advice and enough public checking to keep it honest.

The constitutional base: foreign affairs belong to the Union

The Constitution divides subjects between the Union and the states in the Seventh Schedule. Foreign affairs sit firmly in List I, the Union List. Entries 10 to 21 cover foreign affairs, diplomatic, consular and trade representation, the United Nations, international conferences, entering into and implementing treaties, war and peace, citizenship, extradition, passports and visas, pilgrimages abroad, and piracy.

The constitutional base of foreign policy

So only the Union can deal with foreign countries. A state government cannot sign a treaty with Nepal or open an embassy in Dubai, even if many of its people work there.

Who acts: the executive. Under Article 73(1), the executive power of the Union extends to every matter on which Parliament can make laws. It also extends to rights and authority that the Government of India exercises by virtue of any treaty or agreement. In practice, this means the Union government negotiates and signs treaties as an executive act.

Where law is needed: Article 253. Some treaties need new laws to work inside India, for example a convention that requires changes to criminal or environmental law. Article 253 gives Parliament power to make any law for the whole or any part of India to implement a treaty, agreement or convention, or a decision of an international conference or body. This power applies notwithstanding the normal split of subjects, so Parliament can legislate even on a State List subject to honour a treaty.

Why it matters: this design gives India one voice abroad and lets it act quickly, but it also means Parliament's role is mostly after the fact. That trade-off is a recurring Mains debate.

The Prime Minister, the Cabinet and the security system

In a parliamentary system, real executive power rests with the Prime Minister and the Council of Ministers. Big foreign policy choices, such as a major treaty, a new strategic partnership or a response to a border crisis, are taken at this level. The External Affairs Minister leads the ministry, but the Prime Minister often sets the overall direction and personally drives key relationships through summits.

The decision pyramid

The most sensitive decisions go to the Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS), a small group of senior ministers. For example, the CCS reviewed the operation of India's nuclear doctrine on 4 January 2003. That doctrine says nuclear retaliation can be authorised only by the civilian political leadership through the Nuclear Command Authority, whose Political Council is chaired by the Prime Minister.

The National Security Council (NSC). For long-term security thinking, India has a National Security Council. It is headed by the Prime Minister, with the Ministers of Home Affairs, Defence, External Affairs and Finance as members, and the National Security Adviser (NSA) as its Secretary.

It was created in 1998 under Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee, although the idea had been discussed since Nehru's time. Before that, the Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs took such decisions, and Prime Ministers leaned on a trusted adviser instead of a formal NSA.

The NSC works through three tiers. The Strategic Policy Group, chaired by the Cabinet Secretary, is the main forum for coordination among ministries. The National Security Advisory Board brings in outside experts who give the government inputs on security issues. The NSC Secretariat supports the whole system.

Why it matters: foreign policy today touches defence, trade, energy, technology and internal security all at once. A coordinating body near the Prime Minister helps join these threads, though critics say it also pulls decision-making away from the MEA and from Parliament.

The Ministry of External Affairs and the Foreign Service

The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) is tasked with framing the country's foreign policy and diplomatic relations. It turns the leadership's broad choices into daily action: drafting positions, negotiating agreements, running missions abroad and serving Indian citizens overseas.

Inside the MEA

When it began. At independence in 1947, the British-era Foreign and Political Department became the new Ministry of External Affairs and Commonwealth Relations. The change was almost seamless, which let the new country start conducting its own diplomacy immediately.

The Indian Foreign Service (IFS). Just before independence, in 1946, the government created the Indian Foreign Service. Its officers are recruited through the combined Civil Services examination, and the first batch under this system joined in 1948. New entrants train first with other services and then at the institute for diplomats.

How the MEA is organised. Territorial divisions handle bilateral political and economic work, country by country or region by region. Functional divisions look after subjects that cut across countries, such as policy planning, the UN, consular services and development partnership. Inside the ministry, officers rise from Under Secretary to Secretary; abroad, a diplomat begins as a Third Secretary.

How the diplomatic service was built

Training diplomats. The Foreign Service Training Institute was approved by the Cabinet on 20 December 1983 and began work in January 1986. It was renamed the Foreign Service Institute in 1993 and the Sushma Swaraj Institute of Foreign Service on 14 February 2020.

Why it matters: a large country with interests on every continent needs a strong professional service. A recurring criticism is that India's diplomatic service is small for its size, so missions are stretched and long-term planning suffers.

Parliament: questions, debates, committees and laws

Parliament does not run foreign policy day to day, but it shapes and checks it in four ways. Each gives elected representatives a voice in decisions that the executive takes.

Where Parliament steps in

Questions and debates. Members ask the External Affairs Minister questions in both Houses, and the answers go on record. Major events, such as a border crisis or a big agreement, are debated, and the government must explain its stand.

Money. Parliament votes the budget of the Ministry of External Affairs. Without that vote, missions cannot run and development projects cannot be funded.

Committees. The Committee on External Affairs is one of Parliament's Departmentally Related Standing Committees. It has 31 members, 10 of them from the Rajya Sabha. It examines the ministry's work in detail, away from the noise of the floor, and its reports often push the government on issues such as the size of the diplomatic service.

Laws. When a treaty needs a law to work inside India, Parliament passes it under Article 253. Here, Parliament's role is decisive, because without the law the treaty cannot be enforced in Indian courts.

The limit. Parliament is not required to approve a treaty before the government signs it. Some members and scholars argue that major treaties, especially those that affect territory, trade or citizens' rights, should be placed before Parliament first, as many democracies do.

States, other ministries and public voices

Foreign affairs are a Union subject, but the states are not silent. Many states share a land or sea border with a neighbour, share rivers with one, or send large numbers of workers abroad. Their governments therefore have strong views on deals that affect them.

Border states and the wider circle of voices

A border state may worry about a river-water agreement, a fishing dispute, refugee flows or cross-border trade. Because the Union needs the state's cooperation to implement such deals on the ground, a state's objection can delay or reshape an agreement. This is sometimes called paradiplomacy or the federal dimension of foreign policy.

Other ministries also have a big say. Commerce negotiates trade deals, Defence handles military ties and arms purchases, Finance manages loans and multilateral banks, and Home handles borders and visas. Good policy needs these ministries to pull in the same direction, which is why coordination bodies matter.

Outside government, think tanks, business chambers, the media, the diaspora and public opinion all push ideas and set limits. In an age of social media, public reaction to a border clash or a hostile statement can shape the government's response within hours.

Why it matters: the formal answer to "who makes foreign policy" is the Union executive. The real answer is a wider circle of voices, and a wise government listens to them before committing India abroad.

When, where and why: why the Constitution centralised foreign policy

The setting. India became free in 1947 amid partition, war in Kashmir, refugee flows and the start of the Cold War. The new state could not afford many voices speaking for it abroad, or provinces cutting their own deals with neighbours. Unity in foreign affairs was seen as a matter of survival.

The choice. The framers therefore placed foreign affairs, treaties, war and peace, and citizenship in the Union List. They gave the executive the power to act through Article 73 and gave Parliament the power to implement treaties through Article 253, even on state subjects. At the same time, the ministry built on the old Foreign and Political Department, so that diplomacy could continue without a break.

The implications. The design has served India well in crises, because decisions can be taken quickly and with one voice. Its costs are also clear. Parliament's role is mostly after the fact, states feel left out of deals that affect them, and a lot depends on the judgment of a small circle near the Prime Minister.

The current debate. As foreign policy touches more domestic issues, such as trade, water, climate and migration, demands are growing for more consultation. Proposals include placing major treaties before Parliament, giving the Committee on External Affairs a bigger role, and creating regular channels for border states to be heard.

Mains lens: should Parliament ratify treaties?

1. The case for parliamentary approval. Treaties can change borders, trade rules and citizens' lives, so elected representatives should approve the big ones. Approval would add legitimacy at home and strengthen India's hand abroad, because negotiators could point to Parliament's limits. It would also make the executive explain its choices in public.

2. The case against. Diplomacy often needs speed and secrecy, and a long approval process could make India a slow partner. A divided Parliament might block deals that serve the long-term national interest. The present system already gives Parliament a decisive role through Article 253 whenever a treaty needs a law.

3. The federal angle. States affected by river, border or fishing deals want a voice, and their cooperation is needed to implement such deals. A middle path is structured consultation with affected states before signing, without giving any single state a veto over national policy.

4. A balanced conclusion. A good answer can suggest a tiered approach: routine agreements stay with the executive, while treaties on territory, defence or major trade come before Parliament or its committee. This keeps India's ability to act quickly while adding democratic checks where the stakes are highest.

Mains practice: five questions, five angles

These are practice questions written by us, not past papers. Past questions from each exam are in the PYQ panel of this module.

Angle Question Key points to cover
Constitution Explain the constitutional provisions on the treaty-making power in India. Cite List I entries 10 to 21, Article 73 for executive action and Article 253 for implementing laws. Then note that prior approval by Parliament is not required.
Institutions Discuss the role of the National Security Council in India's foreign and security policy. Describe its composition under the Prime Minister and its three tiers. Then weigh better coordination against concerns about centralisation and the MEA's diminished role.
Parliament "Parliament's role in foreign policy is largely symbolic." Critically examine. Show its real tools, such as questions, budgets, the Committee on External Affairs and Article 253 laws. Then accept that it has no prior say on treaties and suggest reforms.
Federalism How far should states have a say in foreign policy? Explain why foreign affairs are a Union subject and why border states still matter for implementation. Then propose consultation without a state veto.
Capacity Is India's diplomatic machinery equal to its global ambitions? Describe the MEA's structure, the Foreign Service and its training institute. Then discuss the small size of the service and ways to bring in specialists and expand capacity.

How to use this table: each answer should first state the formal rule, then show how practice differs, and end with a balanced reform.

Quick revision

  • Foreign affairs, treaties, war and peace, the UN and citizenship are in entries 10 to 21 of the Union List, so only the Union deals with foreign countries.
  • Under Article 73(1), the Union's executive power covers treaty rights, so the government negotiates and signs treaties as an executive act.
  • Article 253 lets Parliament make laws to implement treaties for the whole or any part of India, even on State List subjects.
  • Parliament's approval is not required before a treaty is signed, which is a common exam trap.
  • The Cabinet Committee on Security reviewed the nuclear doctrine on 4 January 2003, and only the civilian political leadership can authorise nuclear retaliation.
  • The National Security Council is headed by the Prime Minister, its members are the Home, Defence, External Affairs and Finance Ministers, and the NSA is its Secretary.
  • The NSC's three tiers are the Strategic Policy Group under the Cabinet Secretary, the National Security Advisory Board and the NSC Secretariat.
  • In 1947 the Foreign and Political Department became the Ministry of External Affairs and Commonwealth Relations, and the Foreign Service had been created in 1946.
  • The diplomats' institute was renamed the Sushma Swaraj Institute of Foreign Service on 14 February 2020.
  • The Committee on External Affairs has 31 members, including 10 from the Rajya Sabha.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 11 answered

  1. Entering into treaties and agreements with foreign countries is listed in:

  2. Consider the following statements: 1. Under Article 253, Parliament can make a law to implement a treaty even on a subject in the State List. 2. The Constitution requires Parliament's approval before the government signs any treaty. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  3. Which Article extends the executive power of the Union to rights and authority exercisable by virtue of any treaty or agreement?

  4. Who is the Secretary of the National Security Council?

  5. The Strategic Policy Group, the principal forum for inter-ministerial coordination under the NSC, is chaired by:

  6. Under India's nuclear doctrine reviewed in January 2003, nuclear retaliation can be authorised only by:

  7. Consider the following statements: 1. The Indian Foreign Service was created in 1946, before independence. 2. Officers of the Indian Foreign Service are recruited through the combined Civil Services examination. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  8. The Foreign Service Institute was renamed the Sushma Swaraj Institute of Foreign Service in:

  9. How many members does Parliament's Committee on External Affairs have?

  10. In 1947, the Foreign and Political Department became the:

  11. India's National Security Council was created in:

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Learn with AI

A tutor that asks instead of telling, a partner that argues the other side, and this chapter told through your own district.

Tell the tutor what you are stuck on. It will guide you with questions and give the answer after a few tries.

Frequently asked questions

Does Parliament have to approve treaties in India?

No. The executive signs and ratifies treaties; Parliament's role comes when a law is needed to implement them, as with the 2015 Land Boundary Agreement, which needed a constitutional amendment.

When was the National Security Council set up?

In 1998, with the National Security Adviser as its key official.

Which article lets Parliament implement treaties even on state subjects?

Article 253.

Which amendment implemented the India-Bangladesh land boundary deal?

The 100th Constitutional Amendment Act, 2015.

More in this module: Foundations of India's foreign policy

Official sources

Facts in this chapter were checked against these official sources.

  1. Constitution of India, Legislative Department edition as on 1 May 2024 (Arts 73, 253; Seventh Schedule List I)
  2. MEA: About us
  3. MEA: Indian Foreign Service (updated 27 Mar 2026)
  4. Sushma Swaraj Institute of Foreign Service: history
  5. PIB: National Policy on Security, MHA reply in Lok Sabha (16 Dec 2014)
  6. PIB: Meeting of National Security Advisory Board (18 Dec 2002)
  7. PIB: CCS reviews progress in operationalizing India's nuclear doctrine (4 Jan 2003)
  8. Lok Sabha: Parliamentary Committees, Chapter III
  9. IGNOU BPSE-142 Block 1: India's foreign policy, evolution and making