Module 1 · 19 min read · Free chapter
What are international relations? States, sovereignty, power and national interest
International relations studies how states and other actors deal with each other. Each state is sovereign, with no world government above it, so countries rely on power, alliances, law and diplomacy to protect their national interest. Realists stress power and security, liberals stress institutions, trade and cooperation, and constructivists stress ideas and identity. These lenses help explain India's choices.
Start from zero: a mohalla with no police station
Imagine a lane with five houses, but no police station, no court and no municipal office anywhere nearby. Each family has its own gate, its own lock and its own rules inside the house. Nobody can order the others what to cook or whom to invite.
Still, the families have to live together. They share the lane, the drain and the water pipe. One family wants to build a taller wall, another wants to park a tractor in the lane, and a third wants everyone to pay for a new streetlight.
So the families talk, bargain, make friends, form little groups and sometimes quarrel. A rich family may lend money to a poorer one and expect support in return. A large family may simply push the others around, unless they join hands against it.
This lane is a small model of the world. The houses are countries, the lane is the international system, and the way the families deal with one another is international relations (IR). This chapter builds the basic ideas, the state, sovereignty, power and national interest, that every later chapter on India's foreign policy uses.
The state and sovereignty: who is a player?
In IR, a country is usually called a state. Here "state" does not mean Bihar or Kerala; it means a whole country such as India, Nepal or France. A state needs four things: a population, a territory with borders, a government that runs it, and sovereignty.
Sovereignty is the most important of the four. It means two things together. Inside its borders, the state has the final say over laws, taxes and police. Outside, no other state or body stands above it, so it deals with others as an equal.
The world's main rulebook accepts this idea. The UN Charter says in Article 2(1) that the United Nations "is based on the principle of the sovereign equality of all its Members". So Nepal and the United States each get one vote in the UN General Assembly, even though one is far bigger and richer.
The Charter also protects the inner side of sovereignty. Article 2(7) bars the UN from intervening in matters essentially within a state's domestic jurisdiction, except when the Security Council takes enforcement action. This is why India insists that questions such as the internal administration of Jammu and Kashmir are its own business.
Today the United Nations has 193 Member States. Besides states, many non-state actors also shape world affairs: international organisations, big companies, NGOs, terror groups and even individuals with huge online followings.
Why it matters: almost every IR debate is a tug between sovereignty and something bigger. Climate change, trade rules and human rights all ask states to accept limits, and states agree only when they see a gain in it.
No world government: anarchy and the rules that tame it
Go back to the lane with no police station. In IR, this situation has a name: anarchy. It does not mean chaos or constant fighting. It simply means there is no world government above states that can make laws for them and punish those who break them.
Because nobody above them guarantees their safety, states have to look after themselves. This is called self-help. A state that feels unsafe builds up its army, but its neighbour then feels unsafe too and does the same. This spiral is known as the security dilemma, and it explains many arms races.
Yet the world is not a jungle, because states have written rules they mostly follow. The UN Charter asks all Members, in Article 2(3), to settle disputes by peaceful means. In Article 2(4) it asks them to refrain from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state.
There are two exceptions to the ban on force. First, Article 51 preserves the inherent right of self-defence if an armed attack occurs, until the Security Council acts. Second, the Security Council itself can authorise force to keep peace.
The Council has fifteen members: five permanent ones and ten elected by the General Assembly. Under Article 27(3), a decision on substantive matters needs nine votes, including the concurring votes of the permanent members. In practice, this gives each of the five a veto, which is why the Council often freezes when great powers disagree.
Why it matters: India's security planning, from its nuclear deterrent to its border roads, starts from the fact that no outside power will guarantee its safety. At the same time, India relies on the Charter rules when it argues against terror attacks from across its borders.
Power: what lets a country get its way
In the lane, the family with the most sons, the most money or the most respect usually gets its way. Countries are no different. Power in IR is the ability of a state to make others do what it wants, or to stop them from doing what it does not want.
Power comes in three broad forms. Hard power is military strength: soldiers, missiles, warships and the ability to use them. Economic power is the pull of a large market, investment, loans and control over things others need, such as oil, chips or rare minerals.
Soft power is the power to attract rather than to force. It comes from a country's culture, values, ideas and the example it sets. When students across Africa train in Indian institutes, when the world practises yoga, or when India's digital payment model is copied abroad, India gains goodwill that no army can buy.
Power is always relative. India is a giant next to Bhutan but a smaller economy next to China. That is why a state's choices depend not just on its own strength but on the balance around it.
A state can also add to its power by joining others. When weaker states team up against a stronger one, it is called balancing. When they join the stronger side instead, hoping to share its gains, it is called bandwagoning.
India has also tried to make the rules themselves a source of strength. The five principles of Panchsheel, first written in the India-China agreement of 29 April 1954, were mutual respect for territorial integrity and sovereignty, non-aggression, non-interference, equality and mutual benefit, and peaceful co-existence. A newly free, militarily weak country used shared rules to protect itself and to win friends.
Why it matters: India's foreign policy today mixes all three kinds of power. It builds its navy, uses its huge market as a bargaining chip, and spreads its development help and culture to win partners.
National interest: what a country is trying to get
Every family in the lane wants the same basic things: to stay safe, to earn well, to be respected and to live by its values. A country's version of these aims is called its national interest. Foreign policy is simply the plan a state follows to protect and advance that interest abroad.
We can picture national interest as rings. At the centre is survival and security: protecting borders, citizens and the political system.
The next ring is prosperity: trade, energy, technology, investment and jobs. Outside that comes status: a respected voice in world bodies. The outer ring is values and world order: the kind of world a country wants to live in.
India's Constitution gives its own guide here. Article 51, a Directive Principle, asks the State to endeavour to promote international peace and security, to maintain just and honourable relations between nations, to foster respect for international law and treaty obligations, and to encourage settlement of international disputes by arbitration.
Directive Principles cannot be enforced in court, but they set the direction. That is why Indian diplomacy speaks the language of peace, law and fair rules, even while it protects hard interests such as borders and energy supplies.
National interests sometimes pull against each other. For example, buying cheap oil from one supplier may anger another partner, and a strong stand on a border may hurt trade. Much of foreign policy is about ranking interests and making trade-offs.
Why it matters: in a Mains answer, always ask which interest a policy serves. When India stays neutral in a far-off war, it is usually protecting security and energy interests first, not ignoring the values in the outer ring.
Three lenses for looking at the world
Scholars look at the same event through different lenses, and each lens shows something the others miss. Think of a border stand-off between two big neighbours and see how each lens explains it.
The power lens (realism). This lens says states care first about survival and power, because there is no world government. A border stand-off happens because each side wants to protect or gain territory and will not trust the other's promises. Peace lasts only when power is balanced.
The rules and cooperation lens (liberalism). This lens says states also gain from trade, treaties and international bodies, so cooperation is possible and often wise. A stand-off can be calmed by talks, agreed rules and the cost of losing trade. Institutions such as the UN, the WTO and regional groupings make cooperation easier by building trust.
The ideas and identity lens (constructivism). This lens says that how states see themselves and each other matters as much as tanks or trade. Two countries that see each other as rivals will read every move as a threat, while friends will read the same move calmly. Ideas such as non-alignment or "the world is one family" shape what a country thinks is normal behaviour.
No single lens is right every time. A good answer uses more than one: power explains why the stand-off began, rules explain how it was managed, and ideas explain why public opinion on each side reacted the way it did.
Why it matters: UPSC Mains questions often ask whether a policy is "idealist" or "pragmatic". Knowing these lenses lets you argue both sides and then reach a balanced conclusion.
How the study of IR grew: from Westphalia to Waltz and beyond
Where the state system began. States have dealt with each other for thousands of years, from ancient city-states onwards. The modern system of sovereign states, however, is usually traced to the Peace of Westphalia in 1648, which ended long religious wars in Europe. It replaced a loose religious hierarchy with states that ran their own affairs, and the Treaty of Utrecht (1713) further fixed the idea that a sovereign has no external superior.
A subject born from war. For a long time, IR meant diplomatic history. After the slaughter of the First World War, scholars wanted to study how to prevent war, and in 1919 the Woodrow Wilson Chair of International Relations was set up at Aberystwyth in Wales. The thinking of this period was idealist: it trusted international law, treaties and the League of Nations to keep the peace.
Realism answers back. The League failed to stop the Second World War, and scholars turned to realism. Hans Morgenthau's book Politics Among Nations (1948) became its classic text. Drawing on thinkers such as Machiavelli and Hobbes, classical realists argued that human nature is selfish, there is no world government, and every state pursues power and its own interest.
Neo-realism. In 1979, Kenneth Waltz wrote Theory of International Politics and founded neo-realism. He set aside human nature and said behaviour is shaped by the anarchic structure of the system and the distribution of power among states, and he held bipolarity to be the most stable order. Defensive neo-realists say states seek security, while offensive neo-realists say they seek as much power as possible.
New voices after 1991. Neo-realism could not explain why the Cold War ended peacefully or how globalisation spread. After 1991, critical theories gained ground. Constructivists say states and their interests are shaped by ideas and identity, feminists say gender roles are social, not natural, and post-modernists distrust any single grand story of world politics.
Why it matters. UPSC asks you to judge whether India's choices were 'idealist' or 'realist'. Knowing how each school arose, and what it could not explain, lets you use theory as a tool rather than a label.
When, where and why: how today's world order was built
Why a world body at all? The first half of the twentieth century saw two world wars. Millions died, and the failure to stop aggression early convinced leaders that some common forum and common rules were needed. The answer was the United Nations.
When and where. During the Second World War, the countries fighting the Axis powers signed the Declaration by United Nations in Washington DC on 1 January 1942. India, though still a British colony, was among the signatories. The founding conference met at San Francisco from 25 April to 26 June 1945, and the UN Charter was signed there on 26 June 1945.
India's place in it. India is therefore a founding member of the UN, even though it became independent only in 1947. Over the next decades it used the UN to push for the end of colonial rule and racial discrimination, causes that mattered deeply to a country that had just won its own freedom.
What the Charter set out to do. Its purposes, listed in Article 1, are to maintain international peace and security, to develop friendly relations among nations based on equal rights and self-determination, to achieve cooperation on common problems, and to be a centre for harmonising the actions of nations. The UN began in 1945 and has grown to 193 Member States.
The implication: a mixed system. The Charter mixes two ideas. It treats all states as sovereign equals in the General Assembly, but it gives five powers a special place in the Security Council. This mix of equality and hierarchy is the root of India's long demand for reform of the Council.
The vocabulary of IR: words you will meet in every chapter
Before moving to India's own story, it helps to fix some words. Each of them returns again and again in later chapters and in exam questions.
| Term | What it means | Simple example |
|---|---|---|
| Bilateral | Relations or deals between two countries. | An India-Nepal power trade agreement is bilateral. |
| Multilateral | Cooperation among many countries, usually in a large body. | The UN and the WTO are multilateral bodies. |
| Plurilateral or minilateral | A small group of countries working on chosen issues. | A four-country grouping on the Indo-Pacific is minilateral. |
| Alliance | A formal promise to defend each other in war. | NATO members promise mutual defence. |
| Strategic partnership | Close, long-term cooperation without a duty to fight for each other. | India has strategic partnerships with many major powers. |
| Non-alignment | Staying out of rival military blocs and judging each issue on merit. | India stayed out of both Cold War blocs. |
| Strategic autonomy | Keeping the freedom to make one's own choices, whatever the pressure. | Buying arms from several countries keeps options open. |
| Track II diplomacy | Informal talks among retired officials, scholars and experts. | Think-tank dialogues between two rivals are Track II. |
Two more ideas complete the toolkit. Geopolitics is the study of how geography, such as seas, mountains and choke points, shapes power. Geoeconomics is the use of trade, investment and supply chains as tools of power.
Why it matters: examiners reward precise words. Calling a strategic partnership an "alliance" is a factual error, because India has avoided formal military alliances.
Mains lens: is sovereignty still what it used to be?
1. The case that sovereignty is weakening. Money, data, viruses, carbon and terror do not stop at borders. Global trade rules, climate pledges and human rights norms ask states to accept outside checks. Big technology firms and rating agencies can shape a country's economy more than some governments can.
2. The case that sovereignty is as strong as ever. States still control borders, armies and taxes, and they still decide which rules to sign. The COVID-19 years showed countries closing borders and racing for vaccines on their own. Many states, India among them, guard their freedom of choice more firmly than before.
3. India's position. India supports reformed multilateralism: shared rules and strong global bodies, but bodies in which developing countries have a fair voice. It accepts rules it helps to write, and it resists rules that seem imposed by a few powers. This fits its constitutional guide in Article 51, which values international law and peaceful settlement.
4. A balanced conclusion. Sovereignty has not vanished, but it is now shared and bargained. Countries trade a little freedom for gains they cannot get alone, and the skill of foreign policy lies in getting that bargain right.
Mains practice: five questions, five angles
These are practice questions written by us, not past papers. Past questions from each exam are in the PYQ panel of this module.
| Angle | Question | Key points to cover |
|---|---|---|
| Concept | What is meant by sovereignty? Is it compatible with membership of international organisations? | Define the internal and external sides of sovereignty and cite Article 2(1) and 2(7) of the UN Charter. Then argue that states pool some freedom by choice and can still leave or reshape the bodies they join. |
| Law | Examine the rules on the use of force in the UN Charter. How far do they protect smaller states? | Explain Article 2(4), the self-defence right in Article 51 and Security Council action. Then show how the need for concurring votes of the permanent members can block action when a great power is involved. |
| India | How does Article 51 of the Constitution reflect India's approach to world affairs? | List the four aims of Article 51 and link them to Panchsheel and to India's support for peaceful settlement. Then note that India balances these ideals with hard security needs. |
| Power | "Soft power is no substitute for hard power." Discuss with reference to India. | Define both kinds of power with Indian examples such as development training, culture and the navy. Then conclude that each works best with the other, because goodwill needs strength behind it and strength needs legitimacy. |
| Debate | Is foreign policy driven more by interests or by ideals? Argue with examples. | Use the power lens to show interests at work and the ideas lens to show how values shape choices. Then conclude that lasting policies serve interests in ways that also look fair to others. |
How to use this table: open each answer with a one-line definition, give the why with an Indian example, and close with a balanced way forward.
Quick revision
- International relations is the study of how states and other actors deal with one another in a world with no government above them.
- A state has a population, a territory, a government and sovereignty, which means the final say inside and equality outside.
- Article 2(1) of the UN Charter bases the UN on the sovereign equality of all its Members, and Article 2(7) protects matters of domestic jurisdiction.
- Article 2(3) asks states to settle disputes peacefully, and Article 2(4) bans the threat or use of force against other states.
- Article 51 of the UN Charter keeps the right of self-defence against an armed attack until the Security Council acts.
- The Security Council has fifteen members, five permanent and ten elected, and substantive decisions need the concurring votes of the permanent members.
- Power comes as hard power, economic power and soft power, and it is always measured relative to others.
- Article 51 of the Indian Constitution asks the State to promote peace, keep just and honourable relations, respect international law and encourage arbitration.
- The five Panchsheel principles were first written in the India-China agreement of 29 April 1954.
- India signed the Declaration by United Nations on 1 January 1942, and the UN, founded in 1945, now has 193 Member States.