Module 2 · 12 min read · Free chapter
Settlement, combined footings and rafts
Settlement is immediate plus consolidation plus secondary; in sand most is immediate, in soft clay most comes slowly. Clay settlement uses Sc = [Cc H/(1 + e0)] log[(σ′0 + Δσ)/σ′0] and Tv = cv t / Hd². Differential settlement causes damage, so combined footings, rafts and floating rafts are used on weak or crowded sites.
Start from zero: why foundations sink
Stand on a wet beach and your feet sink a little at once. Stay there and they keep sinking, slowly, as water squeezes out from under them. A building on soil does the same. The downward movement of a foundation is its settlement.
Settlement has three parts:
- Immediate (elastic) settlement, which happens as soon as the load comes, by distortion of the soil without change in volume of water.
- Primary consolidation settlement, which happens slowly in clay as water is squeezed out of the pores.
- Secondary compression, a slow creep of the soil skeleton that continues after the extra pore water pressure is gone.
The split depends on the soil. In sand, water escapes almost at once, so 70 to 80% of the settlement is immediate. In stiff clay about half is immediate. In soft clay only 10 to 25% is immediate and the rest comes over months or years.
Why it matters. A footing can be perfectly safe in shear and still ruin a building by settling too much or unevenly. The allowable bearing pressure is the lower of the shear-safe pressure and the pressure that keeps settlement within limits.
Immediate settlement from elastic theory
If soil is treated as an elastic material with Young's modulus E and Poisson's ratio μ, the settlement of a footing of width B under a pressure q is:
Si = q B (1 − μ²) I / E
The influence factor I depends on the shape of the footing, on whether it is rigid or flexible, and on where the settlement is read. A flexible footing, like a thin tank floor, sinks more at the centre than at the corners. A rigid footing, like a thick concrete block, sinks by the same amount everywhere.
| Shape | Rigid footing I | Flexible, average I |
|---|---|---|
| Circle | 0.79 | 0.85 |
| Square | 0.82 | 0.95 |
| Rectangle L/B = 2 | about 1.12 | larger |
| Rectangle L/B = 5 | about 1.6 | larger |
| Rectangle L/B = 10 | about 2.0 | larger |
For a flexible footing, the centre value is the largest: 1.0 for a circle and 1.12 for a square. The corner value is about half the centre value. A rigid footing settles a little less than the average of a flexible one of the same size.
The weak point of the formula is E. Soil stiffness changes with depth, stress and disturbance, so values from tests on small samples can be far off. In clays, E from undrained tests gives the immediate part only.
Settlement in sand: the Schmertmann method
Sand cannot be sampled without disturbing it, so its settlement is worked out from field tests such as SPT and CPT. A widely used method is Schmertmann's strain influence method. It starts from an observation: the strain below a footing is not largest at the base but a little deeper, and it dies out at a certain depth.
The strain influence factor Iz is drawn as a triangle:
- Square and circular footings: Iz = 0.1 at the base, rising to a peak Izmax at depth B/2, and falling to zero at 2B.
- Strip footings: Iz = 0.2 at the base, peak at depth B, zero at 4B.
The peak value is Izmax = 0.5 + 0.1 √(qnet / σ′v), where σ′v is the effective stress at the depth of the peak. The sand below the footing is split into layers of thickness Δz, each with its own modulus E from CPT or SPT, and:
Si = C1 C2 qnet Σ (Iz / E) Δz
C1 = 1 − 0.5 (σ′0 / qnet) is a depth correction, where σ′0 is the effective overburden at the base; a deeper footing settles less. C2 = 1 + 0.2 log10(t / 0.1) is a creep correction for time t in years, because even sand keeps creeping slowly.
Why it matters. In sand, a footing is usually limited by settlement, not shear. A method that uses field test data directly is more reliable than one that needs an E value from samples that cannot be taken.
Consolidation settlement in clay
In a saturated clay, the footing load is first carried by the pore water as extra pressure. Water flows out slowly because clay has very low permeability, and as it leaves, the load passes to the soil grains and the layer compresses. The theory was covered in the consolidation chapter; here it is applied to a footing.
For a normally consolidated clay layer of thickness H:
Sc = [Cc H / (1 + e0)] log10[(σ′0 + Δσ) / σ′0]
Here σ′0 is the effective overburden pressure at the middle of the layer, Δσ is the stress increase there from the footing (by the 2:1 method or Boussinesq), e0 is the initial void ratio and Cc is the compression index. Cc is the slope of the straight part of the e–log p curve from a laboratory test. A rough estimate is Cc = 0.009 (LL − 10).
For an overconsolidated clay with preconsolidation pressure σ′c, the gentler swelling index Cs applies up to σ′c:
- If σ′0 + Δσ ≤ σ′c: Sc = [Cs H / (1 + e0)] log10[(σ′0 + Δσ) / σ′0].
- If σ′0 + Δσ > σ′c: Sc = [H / (1 + e0)] {Cs log10(σ′c / σ′0) + Cc log10[(σ′0 + Δσ) / σ′c]}.
How long does it take? The time factor is Tv = cv t / Hd², where cv is the coefficient of consolidation and Hd is the drainage path. If sand lies both above and below the clay, water drains both ways and Hd = H/2. If one side is rock or impervious, Hd = H. For average degree of consolidation U up to 60%, Tv = (π/4) U²; above that, Tv = 1.781 − 0.933 log10(100 − U%), which gives T90 = 0.848.
A worked case. A 2.7 m square footing at 1.8 m depth carries 1800 kN. A 2.7 m thick clay layer lies between sand layers, with Cc = 0.62 from the e–log p plot and e0 = 1.18.
At the middle of the clay, σ′0 ≈ 101 kPa. With 2:1 spread, the loaded width there is 2.7 + 4.05 = 6.75 m, so Δσ = 1800 / 6.75² ≈ 39 kPa. Then:
Sc = (0.62 × 2.7 / 2.18) × log10(140/101) ≈ 0.768 × 0.142 ≈ 0.110 m = 110 mm
For time, drainage is double, so Hd = 1.35 m. With cv = 4.96 × 10⁻⁶ m²/min, t90 = 0.848 × 1.35² / (4.96 × 10⁻⁶) ≈ 311,600 minutes, or about 216 days, by which time about 99 mm of the 110 mm has occurred.
How much settlement is acceptable
A building that sinks evenly by 50 mm may show no damage at all. A building whose one corner sinks 25 mm more than the others can crack badly. What harms a structure is mostly differential settlement, the difference between two points, and the angular distortion it causes, which is that difference divided by the distance between the points.
Codes therefore limit both. Typical permissible values for framed buildings are:
| Foundation | Sand | Clay |
|---|---|---|
| Isolated footing, maximum settlement | about 50 mm | about 75 mm |
| Raft, maximum settlement | about 75 mm | about 100 mm |
Angular distortion is commonly limited to about 1/300 for framed buildings and tighter, about 1/500 or less, where cracking of finishes or sensitive machinery matters. Clays are allowed more total settlement because it happens slowly and evenly, giving the structure time to adjust.
Designers reduce differential settlement by keeping the pressure similar under all footings, by joining footings with beams, or by using a raft.
Contact pressure: how the soil pushes back
Designers often assume that the soil pushes up uniformly on the base of a footing. That is only true for a flexible footing. A rigid footing forces the whole base to settle by the same amount, and the soil reacts unevenly to make that happen.
- On clay, a rigid footing has its highest contact pressure at the edges and the lowest at the centre. Clay is cohesive, so the soil just outside the edge also helps carry load, and the edge bites in.
- On sand, a rigid footing has its highest contact pressure at the centre and low pressure at the edges. Sand at the edge has no confinement and cannot carry much, so the load moves inwards.
A flexible footing has uniform contact pressure but settles unevenly: on clay it sags like a dish, more at the centre; on sand it settles more at the edges.
In practice, the uniform pressure assumption is used for the design of ordinary footings because the errors are small and on the safe side for bending. For large rafts, the soil is modelled as springs to get a better picture of moments.
Why it matters. Contact pressure decides the bending moments in a raft or a large footing. Getting its shape wrong can put the steel in the wrong place.
Combined footings and rafts
An isolated footing under each column is the cheapest choice. It stops working well in three situations: when a column stands right at the property line, when two columns are so close that their footings overlap, and when the soil is so weak that footings would cover most of the plan.
A combined footing carries two or more columns. The key rule is that the centroid of the footing area must coincide with the resultant of the column loads, so that the soil pressure is uniform. The common forms are:
- Rectangular, when the loads are similar or the outer column has room to project.
- Trapezoidal, when the outer column at the boundary is the heavier one, so the wider end goes under it.
- Strap (cantilever) footing, where two separate footings are joined by a stiff beam, the strap. The strap carries the overturning from the eccentric edge footing to the inner one, and it does not bear on the soil.
A raft or mat is a single slab under the whole building. It is used when isolated footings would cover more than about half the plan area, on soft or erratic soil where some footings might settle more than others, and over pockets or cavities. Because it bridges weak spots, a raft reduces differential settlement.
A floating or compensated raft goes one step further. The basement excavation removes soil whose weight roughly equals the weight of the building. The net pressure on the soil is then close to zero, and settlement is small even on soft clay.
Why it matters. Most city plots in India are narrow, with columns right on the boundary. Combined and strap footings are what make those buildings possible without trespassing below the neighbour.
Descriptive lens: how this topic is asked in written papers
Written papers usually ask settlement and foundation choice in these ways:
- Explain the components of settlement and how they differ in sand and clay.
- Compute consolidation settlement and the time for a given degree of consolidation.
- Discuss permissible, differential settlement and angular distortion.
- Justify the choice of a combined footing, strap footing or raft for a given site.
Practice questions (our own, not previous-year questions).
- What are the components of total settlement? Why is immediate settlement a large share in sand but a small share in soft clay? (10 marks)
- Explain contact pressure distribution under rigid and flexible footings on clay and sand, with sketches. (10 marks)
- A 3 m thick normally consolidated clay layer, drained at top and bottom, has e0 = 1.0, Cc = 0.3 and σ′0 = 80 kPa at mid-depth. A building raises the stress there by 40 kPa. Find the consolidation settlement and the time for 90% consolidation if cv = 2 m²/year. (15 marks)
Answer plan for question 3.
- Sc = (0.3 × 3 / 2) × log10(120/80) = 0.45 × 0.176 ≈ 0.079 m ≈ 79 mm.
- Double drainage: Hd = 1.5 m; T90 = 0.848.
- t90 = 0.848 × 1.5² / 2 ≈ 0.95 year, about 11.5 months.
- Comment: about 71 mm will occur within a year; if this is too slow or too much for the structure, consider preloading with vertical drains, or a compensated raft.
Quick revision
- Total settlement = immediate + primary consolidation + secondary.
- Immediate share: sand 70–80%, stiff clay about 50%, soft clay 10–25%.
- Si = q B (1 − μ²) I / E; rigid square I = 0.82, circle 0.79.
- Schmertmann: Iz peak at B/2 (square) or B (strip); zero at 2B or 4B.
- Sc = [Cc H / (1 + e0)] log[(σ′0 + Δσ)/σ′0], at mid-layer; Cc ≈ 0.009 (LL − 10).
- Tv = cv t / Hd²; T90 = 0.848; double drainage Hd = H/2.
- Damage comes from differential settlement and angular distortion.
- Rigid footing contact pressure: clay highest at edges, sand highest at centre.
- Combined footing: centroid at the resultant; trapezoidal wide end under the heavier column.
- Raft when footings cover more than about half the plan; floating raft balances load with excavated soil.