Module 2 · 11 min read · Free chapter
Stability of slopes: infinite slopes, slip circles and slices
Slope safety compares available shear strength with what is needed on the slip surface. A dry sand slope has F = tan φ / tan i, roughly halved by seepage. Clay slopes use circular slip surfaces, slices and Bishop's method; dams are checked at end of construction, steady seepage and sudden drawdown.
Start from zero: why slopes slide
Every slope of soil is a balance. Gravity pulls each part of it downhill, and the soil's shear strength holds it back. As long as strength wins along every possible surface inside the slope, it stands. When gravity wins along any one surface, the mass above that surface slides.
This happens to natural hill slopes, to cuttings for roads and railways, to embankments for highways and canals, and to earth dams. In India, landslides close hill roads in the Himalaya and the Western Ghats every monsoon. Canal and river embankments slump after floods.
Two kinds of change set a slope off. A change in total stress, such as new fill on top or a cut at the toe, increases the driving force or removes support. A change in pore water pressure, most often from rain, lowers the effective stress and so the strength, even though the slope's shape has not changed at all.
Why it matters. Slope stability brings together soil strength, seepage and geometry. It is also how failures of retaining walls and foundations on sloping ground are checked.
Factor of safety and kinds of failure
The factor of safety of a slope compares the strength the soil can offer with the strength it must use to stay in balance along a chosen slip surface:
F = available shear strength / mobilised shear stress
F = 1 means the slope is on the point of failure. Designs usually aim for about 1.3 to 1.5, depending on how well the soil is known and what a failure would cost. Because nobody knows in advance where the slip surface will form, many trial surfaces are checked, and the lowest F found is the factor of safety of the slope.
Slips take two broad shapes:
- Translational slides move on a plane roughly parallel to the surface. They happen in long, shallow slopes, in loose soil over rock, or along a weak layer. These are analysed as infinite slopes.
- Rotational slides move on a curved surface, close to a circular arc, typical of homogeneous clay. A face failure cuts the slope face above the toe. A toe failure passes through the toe, common in steep slopes. A base failure dips below the toe and comes up some distance in front of it, common in flatter slopes on deep soft clay.
Infinite slopes
An infinite slope is one so long compared to the depth of the slip that every slice of it is the same as every other. Take a slice of soil of vertical depth z, resting on a plane parallel to the surface at slope angle i. Its weight splits into a part normal to the plane, which presses it down and creates friction, and a part along the plane, which drives it downhill.
For dry cohesionless soil, the depth cancels out completely, and:
F = tan φ / tan i
The slope is stable as long as i < φ, and just on the point of sliding when i = φ. This is why the angle of repose of dry sand equals its angle of internal friction in the loose state, as the sand cone in the shear strength chapter showed.
Now let water seep parallel to the slope with the water table at the surface, as happens on a hillside during long rain. The driving force uses the full saturated weight, but the friction depends only on the effective weight:
F = (γ′ / γsat) × (tan φ / tan i)
Since γ′/γsat is roughly one half for most soils, seepage parallel to the slope roughly halves the factor of safety. A sandy slope at 25° that is comfortably safe when dry can fail during heavy rain.
Put numbers on it. A sand slope has φ = 32°, i = 25° and γsat = 20 kN/m³. Dry, F = tan 32° / tan 25° = 0.625 / 0.466 ≈ 1.34, which is acceptable. With full seepage parallel to the slope, γ′/γsat = 10.19/20 ≈ 0.51, so F ≈ 0.51 × 1.34 ≈ 0.68, and the slope fails.
For a c-φ soil, cohesion adds a term that shrinks with depth:
F = c / (γ z cos² i tan i) + tan φ / tan i
If the slope is steeper than φ, the friction term alone is below 1, and the slope can stand only to a critical depth:
zc = c / [γ cos² i (tan i − tan φ)]
Why it matters. Shallow landslides on monsoon hill roads are mostly infinite-slope failures of a soil layer over rock, set off by seepage. Drains that keep the water table below the slip plane are the single most effective fix.
Finite slopes: slip circles and slices
A finite slope, such as an embankment or a cutting, has a definite top and toe, and in uniform clay it fails on a curved surface. The classic tool is the slip circle.
For a saturated clay loaded quickly, use φ = 0 and the undrained cohesion c. This is the Swedish circle or φ = 0 method.
Draw a trial circle of radius r about a centre O. The sliding mass has weight W, acting at a horizontal distance x from O, and tries to rotate about O. Cohesion acts along the arc length L, at radius r, and resists:
F = c L r / (W x)
Many centres and radii are tried, and the circle with the lowest F is the critical circle. If tension cracks form near the top, the arc is shortened by the crack depth and water in the crack adds a driving force.
When the soil has friction as well, the resistance on the arc depends on the normal stress, which varies along it. The answer is to cut the sliding mass into vertical slices, usually 10 to 20. For each slice, with weight W, base length l, base angle α and pore pressure u, the ordinary method of slices (Fellenius) gives:
F = Σ[c′ l + (W cos α − u l) tan φ′] / Σ W sin α
This method ignores the forces between slices, which makes it simple and slightly conservative. Bishop's simplified method includes the horizontal forces between slices and satisfies the balance of moments. Its formula has F on both sides, so it is solved by iteration: assume F, calculate, and repeat until the value settles, usually in three or four rounds. It usually gives a factor of safety a little higher than Fellenius, and closer to rigorous methods.
Taylor ran the circle method for many simple slopes and summed up the results in the stability number:
Sn = c / (F γ H)
Charts give Sn for each slope angle and φ, so the safe height or the factor of safety of a simple slope can be read off quickly. For φ = 0, steep slopes of more than about 53° fail by toe circles, while flatter slopes over deep clay can fail by base circles.
Why it matters. Every highway embankment on soft ground in the Indo-Gangetic plain is checked with slip circles. Bishop's method, run on a spreadsheet or program, is the everyday design tool.
Critical conditions and remedies
The same slope can be safe at one stage of its life and unsafe at another, because the pore pressures change. For an earth dam or embankment, three conditions are checked:
- End of construction. Fill placed quickly builds up pore pressure in clay that has no time to drain. Both slopes are checked, using undrained strength or effective strength with the measured pore pressures.
- Steady seepage. With the reservoir full for a long time, water seeps through the dam. The downstream slope is critical, because seepage forces push towards it.
- Sudden drawdown. If the reservoir is lowered quickly, the water that was supporting the upstream face is gone, but the soil inside is still full of water at high pore pressure. The upstream slope is then at its most dangerous.
When a slope is found unsafe, the fixes follow from F = resisting / driving:
- Reduce the driving force: flatten the slope, cut back or unload the top.
- Add resistance at the toe: place a berm or counterweight fill there.
- Lower the pore pressure: horizontal drains, trench drains, relief wells and surface drains that keep rain out of cracks. Drainage is often the cheapest and most effective step.
- Reinforce: retaining walls at the toe, piles, soil nails, geogrids, and deep-rooted vegetation for shallow slopes.
Why it matters. Many embankment and dam slips in India have happened soon after a flood, when the river or reservoir fell faster than the embankment could drain. Designing for drawdown and keeping drains working are lessons written in those failures.
Descriptive lens: how this topic is asked in written papers
Written papers test slope stability in four main ways:
- Derive the factor of safety of an infinite slope, dry and with seepage.
- Explain the Swedish circle method, the method of slices or Bishop's method, with a sketch.
- Discuss the critical conditions for an earth dam and why each is critical.
- Suggest remedies for a failing cutting or embankment, with reasons.
Practice questions (our own, not previous-year questions).
- Derive the factor of safety of an infinite slope in cohesionless soil for the dry case and for seepage parallel to the slope. Comment on the effect of seepage. (10 marks)
- Explain the ordinary method of slices and Bishop's simplified method. Why does Bishop's method need iteration? (10 marks)
- A highway cutting in a weathered hill slope in a high-rainfall district has slipped twice in two monsoons. Describe how you would investigate the cause and choose remedial measures. (15 marks)
Answer plan for question 3.
- Start with a site visit and a desk study: rainfall records, geology, the shape and depth of the slips, cracks above the crest, seepage on the face.
- Investigate with boreholes and test pits to find the soil over rock and any weak layer; install piezometers to see how pore pressure rises in rain.
- Back-analyse the slip with F = 1 to find the strength mobilised, using an infinite-slope or slices analysis as the shape suggests.
- Identify the cause: most likely seepage raising pore pressure in a shallow soil layer over rock, possibly with toe cutting during road widening.
- Choose remedies: surface and horizontal drains first, a toe wall or gabion support, flattening or benching where land allows, and bioengineering on the face.
- Conclude with monitoring of drains and piezometers after every monsoon.
Quick revision
- F = available shear strength / mobilised shear stress; the slope's F is the minimum over all trial surfaces.
- Translational slides: infinite slope analysis. Rotational slides: face, toe or base circles.
- Dry sand infinite slope: F = tan φ / tan i; seepage parallel to the slope multiplies it by γ′/γsat, about one half.
- c-φ infinite slope steeper than φ: critical depth zc = c / [γ cos² i (tan i − tan φ)].
- φ = 0 circle: F = c L r / (W x).
- Ordinary slices: F = Σ[c′ l + (W cos α − u l) tan φ′] / Σ W sin α; Bishop adds interslice forces and iterates.
- Taylor: Sn = c / (F γ H).
- Earth dams: end of construction, steady seepage (downstream) and sudden drawdown (upstream).
- Remedies: flatten or unload, toe berm, drainage, reinforcement.